Latest revision as of 19:20, 19 July 2009

Multiseat Support

Summary

Make it simple to configure a system for multiseat operation, where two or more users each have their own keyboard, monitor, and mouse, and can work independently of each other.

Owner

Name: Ctyler chris at tylers dot info

Current status

Targeted release: Fedora ?
Last updated: 2009-01-28
Percentage of completion: 10%

Detailed Description

Linux is inherently multiuser, but PC hardware is usually designed with a single local user in mind. However, it's realitively straightforward to add additional video cards, monitors, and mice to provide access for multiple simultaneous users. F8 provided fairly good multiseat support (with significant manual configuration), but recent changes in in device support and X have removed functionality that is needed for multiseat operation. The removed functionality needs to be added back in and be thoroughly tested on a range of hardware.

Multiseat systems are useful in schools, home offices, libraries, Internet cafes, and other settings, and provide savings in power consumption, capital cost, and administration effort when compared to operating multiple PCs.

Benefit to Fedora

Multiseat is a good solution for several use-cases, and will clearly showcase Fedora's flexibility. However, it is also expected to yield improvements in the robustness of device support for single-user configurations.

Note: Fedora currently has multiseat users (release <= F8) who are now using EOL releases. Adding good multiseat support will enable those users to upgrade to a current Fedora release and make it easy for additional users to configure multiseat systems.

Scope

Requires packaging or testing and/or enhancements in:

GDM
- GDM 2.22 dropped support for configuring multiple local servers via configuration files. To start multiple seats, we will need to: (a) have ConsoleKit tell GDM what seats are available, (b) add the config-file functionality back in, or (c) configure multiseat using one of the other display managers.
ConsoleKit
- If approach (a) is selected above, ConsoleKit will need to be configurable for multiple seats. (I can't see an easy way for it to automatically determine keyboard-pointer-video groupings).
- Decide how to handle multiple concurrent local users for for sound, USB, and removable-media drives.
PulseAudio
- Adjustments to default configuration to better support multiple local users?
udev
- X is now configured with all input devices, even those hotplugged after the X server starts. For multiseat operation, this is not desirable.
- udev rules could be used to assign devices to specific displays (:0, :1, ...)
Kernel
- Get VGA arbitration/multi-card POSTing into the kernel for multicard multiseat (this was removed from X in the F9 timeframe)
X
- Fix/restore --noswitchvt/-sharevts functionality
- Adjust to work with udev display assignment
- Test that evdev can be configured to use specific devices only (vs. all input devices)
- Determine which video card and driver combinations work in a multi-seat configuration (e.g., Nouveau is reported not to work with multiple cards at this time)
Xephyr
- Confirm operation with evdev input devices
- Adjust to work with udev display assignment

How To Test

Arrange access to systems with a variety of multiseat video configurations.
Test multiseat operation on those platforms.
Work with Fedora QA to ensure that we have sufficient coverage.

User Experience

Users of existing multiseat systems (currently stuck at F8) will be able to update their systems to a current Fedora release.
Users configuring a multiseat system for the first time should find it fairly straightforward.
Multiseat systems should operate with the same reliability as single-seat systems.

Dependencies

Changes noted in "Scope" section

Creation of configuration tool

Contingency Plan

Do not support Multiseat in Fedora -- no change from F9/F10

Documentation

Release Notes

Early days!
Multiseat operation is not yet functional in rawhide/alpha.

Outline:

Description of multiseat capabilities
- Use Cases
  - Home office
  - Kiosk cluster
  - Internet cafe
  - Library
System requirements
- Video, keyboard, mouse
  - Video card combinations known to work
  - Video card combinations known to fail
- General system resources: memory, disk, CPU guidelines for multi-user configuration
Configuring Multiseat
- Installing and configuring MDM
Pointer to Multiseat-related fp.o/wiki pages

Comments and Discussion

See Talk:Features/Multiseat

@@ Line 6: / Line 6: @@
 == Owner ==
-* Name: [[User:Ctyler|Ctyler]]
+* Name: [[User:Ctyler|Ctyler]] chris at tylers dot info
 == Current status ==
-* Targeted release: [[Releases/11|  Fedora 11]]
+* Targeted release: [[Releases/?|  Fedora ?]]
-* Last updated: 2008-11-07
+* Last updated: 2009-01-28
-* Percentage of completion: 2%
+* Percentage of completion: 10%
 == Detailed Description ==
@@ Line 21: / Line 21: @@
 == Benefit to Fedora ==
-Multiseat is a good solution for several use-cases, and will clearly showcase Fedora's flexibility. However, it is also expected to yield improvements robustness of device support for single-user configurations.
+Multiseat is a good solution for several use-cases, and will clearly showcase Fedora's flexibility. However, it is also expected to yield improvements in the robustness of device support for single-user configurations.
-'''Note:''' Fedora currently has multiseat users (release <= F8) who are or are about to be using an EOL release. Adding good multiseat support will enable those users to upgrade to a current Fedora release and make it easy for additional users to configure multiseat systems.
+'''Note:''' Fedora currently has multiseat users (release <= F8) who are now using EOL releases. Adding good multiseat support will enable those users to upgrade to a current Fedora release and make it easy for additional users to configure multiseat systems.
 == Scope ==
-Requires testing and/or enhancements in:
+Requires packaging or testing and/or enhancements in:
 * GDM
-** GDM 2.22 dropped support for configuring multiple local servers via configuration files. To start multiple seats, we will need to: (a) have ConsoleKit tell GDM what seats are available (seems to be the preferred approach), (b) signal GDM to start another local X server (e.g. gdmflexiserver with arguments), (c) add the config-file functionality back in, or (d) configure multiseat using one of the other display managers.
+** GDM 2.22 dropped support for configuring multiple local servers via configuration files. To start multiple seats, we will need to: (a) have ConsoleKit tell GDM what seats are available, (b) add the config-file functionality back in, or (c) configure multiseat using one of the other display managers.
 * ConsoleKit
 ** If approach (a) is selected above, ConsoleKit will need to be configurable for multiple seats. (I can't see an easy way for it to automatically determine keyboard-pointer-video groupings).
 ** Decide how to handle multiple concurrent local users for for sound, USB, and removable-media drives.
-* hal/udev
+* PulseAudio
+** Adjustments to default configuration to better support multiple local users?
+* udev
 ** X is now configured with all input devices, even those hotplugged after the X server starts. For multiseat operation, this is not desirable.
+** udev rules could be used to assign devices to specific displays (:0, :1, ...)
+* Kernel
+** Get VGA arbitration/multi-card POSTing into the kernel for multicard multiseat (this was removed from X in the F9 timeframe)
 * X
+** Fix/restore --noswitchvt/-sharevts functionality
+** Adjust to work with udev display assignment
 ** Test that evdev can be configured to use specific devices only (vs. all input devices)
 ** Determine which video card and driver combinations work in a multi-seat configuration (e.g., Nouveau is reported not to work with multiple cards at this time)
+* Xephyr
+** Confirm operation with evdev input devices
+** Adjust to work with udev display assignment
-A multiseat configuration tool is also needed.
+== How To Test ==
-== Test Plan ==
 # Arrange access to systems with a variety of multiseat video configurations.
@@ Line 55: / Line 63: @@
 == Dependencies ==
-* Updated GDM
+* Changes noted in "Scope" section
-* Updated ConsoleKit
-* Alternate or adapted ruleset for udev
-* X changes and testing
-** Fix --noswitchvt
-** Verify options for non-autodetection of input hardware
-** Test combinations of video cards using various drivers (especially dual ATI, dual Nvidia, onboard Intel+ATI, onboard Intel+Nvidia)
 * Creation of configuration tool
 == Contingency Plan ==
 * Do not support Multiseat in Fedora -- no change from F9/F10
 == Documentation ==
-* (To be written)
+* [http://wiki.c3sl.ufpr.br/multiseat/index.php/Mdm MDM]
+* [http://mail.gnome.org/archives/gdm-list/2008-October/msg00018.html E-mail discussion of the future of multiseat in GDM, looking at gdmdynamic and MDM]
+* [http://www.freedesktop.org/wiki/Software/ConsoleKit ConsoleKit]
+* [https://bugs.freedesktop.org/buglist.cgi?quicksearch=novtswitch X.org bugs related to -novtswitch and -sharevts]
 == Release Notes ==
-* (To be written)
+{{Admon/note | Early days! | Multiseat operation is not yet functional in rawhide/alpha.}}
+Outline:
+* Description of multiseat capabilities
+** Use Cases
+*** Home office
+*** Kiosk cluster
+*** Internet cafe
+*** Library
+* System requirements
+** Video, keyboard, mouse
+*** Video card combinations known to work
+*** Video card combinations known to fail
+** General system resources: memory, disk, CPU guidelines for multi-user configuration
+* Configuring Multiseat
+** Installing and configuring MDM
+* Pointer to Multiseat-related fp.o/wiki pages
+== Comments and Discussion ==
+* See [[Talk:Features/Multiseat]]  <!-- This adds a link to the "discussion" tab associated with your page.  This provides the ability to have ongoing comments or conversation without bogging down the main feature page -->
 ----
-[[Category:FeatureReadyForWrangler]]
+[[Category:FeaturePageIncomplete]]

Search

Features/Multiseat: Difference between revisions