|
|
Line 683: |
Line 683: |
| | {{result|warn}} <ref>ran fine, but slowly <15fps</ref> | | | {{result|warn}} <ref>ran fine, but slowly <15fps</ref> |
| | N/A <ref>sounds like live environment died during test</ref> | | | N/A <ref>sounds like live environment died during test</ref> |
| | | <references/> |
| | |- |
| | | [[User:Elline | Elline]] |
| | | [http://www.smolts.org/client/show/pub_8136fa52-eb79-423d-a7aa-990e6e8edddc HW] |
| | | {{result|warn}} <ref>runs, but very slow</ref> |
| | | {{result|pass}} |
| | | N/A <ref>can't install via liveCD</ref> |
| | | {{result|pass}} |
| | | {{result|pass}} |
| | <references/> | | | <references/> |
| |- | | |- |
Revision as of 17:43, 23 February 2011
Arriving after the date above? If you come to this page after the test day is completed, your testing of Radeon is still valuable, and you can use the information on this page to test Radeon with your graphics card and provide feedback. If you are visiting
after the release of Fedora 15, please wait for the next Radeon test day.
What to test?
Today's Fedora Test Day will focus on the radeon driver for ATI/AMD Radeon graphics cards.
If you come to this page after the test day is completed, your testing is still valuable, and you can use the information on this page to test with your graphics card and provide feedback.
Who's available
The following cast of characters will be available for testing, workarounds, bug fixes, and general discussion...
What's needed to test
Shell support broken on later cardsAll cards of the R600 generation and later - that is, Radeon HD 2xxx and later - are currently believed to be encountering a bug which causes Mutter (the GNOME 3 window manager) to crash when trying to load GNOME Shell -
Bugzilla: #677842. If you encounter this crash, mark the GNOME 3 start test as
fail, link to that bug report, and CC yourself on the report if you would like to follow progress on a fix.
How to test?
Update your machine
If you're running Fedora 42, make sure you have all the current updates for it installed, using the update manager. Or you can use a live image:
Live image
Optionally, you may download a non-destructive Fedora 42 live image for your architecture. Tips on using a live image are available at FedoraLiveCD.
Architecture |
SHA256SUM
|
i686 |
4553b73f8fab46fbb85384974decc7f9595e5c7af6df76e303cef5e62a76e07f
|
x86_64 |
e59d1886f7b766011b89d88369d09a4dd46bd7ba8a25664e9de0430d0f8725d7
|
Testing
Follow each of these test cases:
Multihead test case:
You will need two or more monitors to perform the multihead test.
Optional extended OpenGL test cases (some of these will require you to at least move around in games):
These will provide more detailed testing of 3D functionality. Please file bugs for any failures you find if running these tests.
Report your results
If you have problems with any of the tests, report a bug to Bugzilla usually for the component xorg-x11-drv-ati. If you are unsure about exactly how to file the report, just ask on IRC and we will help you. Follow the instructions on this page to ensure you include sufficient information in the report. Once you have completed the tests, add your results to the Results table below, following the example results from Example user as a template. The first column should be your name with a link to your User page in the Wiki if you have one, and the second should be a link to your Smolt hardware profile (see above for a link with instructions on submitting your hardware profile to Smolt). For each test case, use the result template to enter your result, as shown in the example result line. If you could not perform one test (for example, you cannot perform the more advanced tests because the basic one fails, or you cannot perform the multihead test as you have only one display), enter the word N/A. In the comments column, you can enter the model name and PCI device ID (vendor ID is usually 1002) of your card, if you know it - you can usually find this information in the output of the command lspci -nn.
Results
Main tests
User
|
Smolt Profile
|
Basic test
|
GNOME 3 start
|
DPMS
|
XVideo
|
Rotation
|
X restart
|
Rendercheck
|
GLX
|
User switch
|
VT switch
|
Suspend
|
Multihead
|
Comments
|
Example user
|
HW
|
pass
|
pass
|
pass
|
pass
|
pass
|
pass
|
pass
|
pass
|
pass
|
N/A
|
|
|
|
Jorge
|
HW
|
pass
|
pass
|
pass
|
pass
|
pass
|
pass
|
pass
|
|
pass
|
N/A
|
|
|
|
Faelar
|
HW
|
warn [1]
|
pass
|
pass
|
pass
|
fail [2]
|
pass
|
pass [3]
|
pass
|
pass
|
pass
|
N/A
|
N/A
|
- ↑ Artifacts (Non-persistent black horiz. lines)
- ↑ Blank screen, I can't do anything then, reboot forced.
- ↑ renderchecklog.gz
|
NJM
|
HW
|
pass
|
fail [1]
|
pass
|
fail [2]
|
pass
|
pass
|
pass
|
pass
|
pass
|
pass
|
pass
|
N/A
|
- ↑ GNOME Shell starts and runs, but misrenders nearly everything.
- ↑ Color corruption outside of the video rectangle
RHBZ: 679579
Several mesa-demo apps misrender. RHBZ: 679588
|
Jaroslav Pulchart
|
HW
|
pass
|
pass
|
pass
|
pass
|
pass
|
warn [1]
|
warn [2]
|
pass
|
inprogress
|
pass
|
inprogress
|
inprogress
|
|
Reinout van Schouwen
|
HW
|
pass
|
pass
|
pass
|
pass
|
pass
|
|
fail [1]
|
pass [2]
|
|
pass
|
|
|
|
Jordan Clarke
|
HW
|
pass
|
pass
|
pass
|
pass
|
pass
|
|
|
pass
|
|
pass
|
|
|
|
MahMahoritos
|
HW
|
pass
|
[2]
|
pass
|
pass
|
pass
|
[3]
|
pass [4]
|
pass
|
fail [5]
|
warn [6]
|
fail [7]
|
warn [8]
|
- ↑ 1.0 1.1 RHBZ #679685
- ↑ Gnome Shell doesn't start
- ↑ Second startx make Gnome Shell working
- ↑ http://www.fpaste.org/LjZa/
- ↑ Can't switch users without Gnome Shell, only log out option available
- ↑ Can't switch back to Gnome, Ctrl+Alt+F1 craches system at all
- ↑ System sleeps (pm-suspend), then wakes up, but I can't run any programm and 'su' in terminal doesn't work
- ↑ HDMI hotplug (after log in) doesn't work at all; if HDMI is connected before system starts, then everything works fine, every display supports its native resolution
|
Philip V
|
HW[1]
|
[3]
|
fail
|
warn [4]
|
warn
|
fail
|
N/A
|
pass [5]
|
pass
|
N/A
|
N/A
|
fail [6]
|
[8]
|
- ↑ 01:00.0 [0300]: ATI RV280 [Radeon 9200 PRO] [1002:5960] (rev 01)
01:00.1 [0380]: ATI RV280 [Radeon 9200 PRO] (Secondary) [1002:5940] (rev 01)
Dual head did work in Fedora 13.
- ↑ RHBZ #679674
- ↑ The default boot always gets stuck immediately. 'Boot Basic Video' succeeds. Not sure how to report the rest of these tests as testcases assume no 'nomodeset'; 'Boot Basic Video' uses 'nomodeset'.
- ↑ All warnings mean: only works with the forbidden 'nomodeset'/'Boot Basic Video'.
- ↑ https://fedoraproject.org/w/uploads/c/c3/Renderchecklog_RV280.txt
- ↑ Resume after Suspend from Login Screen has dead keyboard and Mouse
- ↑ RHBZ #653803
- ↑ xrandr only sees one monitor with 0Hz refresh rate
|
MadRouter
|
HW
|
pass
|
warn [1]
|
pass
|
pass
|
pass
|
pass
|
pass [2]
|
pass
|
pass [3]
|
pass
|
warn [4]
|
pass
|
- ↑ gnome shell does not start after first boot, start successfully after next boots
- ↑ File:Radeon renderchecklog madrouter.gz
- ↑ work fine from gnome 3 shell, N/A from gnome desktop
- ↑ shut down instead of suspend from gnome 3 shell, but work fine from gnome desktop
|
dbkblk
|
HW
|
pass
|
warn [1]
|
pass
|
pass
|
pass
|
pass
|
warn [2]
|
pass
|
warn [3]
|
warn [4]
|
warn [5]
|
N/A
|
- ↑ Gnome shell does not start after first boot (fallback mode), start successfully when logout > login. OK with "gnome-shell --replace".
- ↑ 44 steps/46. [1](Didn't understood how to upload it here)
- ↑ The switch worked but when i log out the 2nd user, it fall back into the 1st user session and not gdm !!
Moreover, the insight of the overlay window show 3 same nautilus thumbnails instead of the correct thumbnails.
- ↑ Works, but unusable because a message keep showing each second: “[random numbers...] hub 1-0:1.0 Unable to enumerate USB device on port 2“
- ↑ Works with “pm-suspend” but the suspend menu of gnome 3 shut down the computer instead of suspending it.
|
Wyatt Gosling
|
HW
|
warn [1]
|
pass
|
pass
|
pass
|
pass
|
pass
|
pass [2]
|
pass
|
pass
|
pass
|
pass
|
warn [3]
|
- ↑ Artifacts between Plymouth and login screens.
- ↑ only 44 of 46 passed. [2]
- ↑ xrardr output [3]. Login screen chose correct screen as primary, but the session did not. Gnome 3's config tool did not provide a means to fix this. Physically unplugging the display was required for desired behavior.
|
Mira
|
HW
|
pass
|
warn [1]
|
pass
|
pass
|
pass
|
pass
|
pass
|
pass
|
pass
|
pass
|
fail [2]
|
N/A
|
- ↑ Always after 1st log-in Gnome in fallback mode, after log-out log-in Gnome shell started
- ↑ System didn't suspend successfully, it just simply switched off
|
geopan
|
HW
|
pass
|
pass
|
pass
|
pass
|
pass
|
pass
|
inprogress [1]
|
pass
|
pass
|
pass
|
pass
|
N/A multihead
|
- ↑ only 44 of 46 passed, but was unable to upload renderchecklog
|
lersek
|
FIXME add link later
|
pass
|
pass
|
pass
|
pass
|
pass
|
pass
|
fail [1]
|
pass [2]
|
pass
|
pass
|
warn [3]
|
N/A
|
- ↑ 44 tests passed of 46 total [4].
- ↑ glxgears synced to monitor refresh rate, 60Hz.
- ↑ Desktop machine powered off completely.
|
Spiro
|
HW
|
pass
|
pass
|
pass
|
pass
|
pass
|
pass
|
pass
|
pass
|
pass
|
pass
|
pass
|
N/A
|
|
Ivo Anjo
|
HW [1]
|
pass
|
pass
|
pass
|
fail
|
pass
|
pass
|
pass [2]
|
pass
|
pass
|
pass
|
pass
|
pass
|
|
Vlads
|
HW
|
pass
|
pass
|
pass
|
pass
|
pass
|
pass [1]
|
pass
|
pass
|
N/A
|
pass
|
warning [2]
|
N/A
|
|
domk
|
HW
|
pass
|
pass
|
pass
|
pass
|
pass
|
pass
|
N/A
|
pass
|
pass
|
pass
|
pass
|
N/A
|
RS780M/RS780MN Radeon HD 3200 [1002:9612]
|
Marek Zdunek
|
HW[1]
|
pass
|
|
pass
|
pass
|
|
|
warn [7]
|
warn [8]
|
pass
|
pass
|
N/A[9]
|
N/A
|
|
User:pfps
|
HW
|
pass
|
fail [1]
|
none
|
none
|
none
|
none
|
none
|
none
|
none
|
none
|
none
|
none
|
- ↑ repeated crashes in mutter
|
MC
|
HW
|
pass
|
fail [1]
|
pass
|
pass
|
pass
|
warn [2]
|
fail [3]
|
fail [4]
|
warn [5]
|
pass
|
warn [6]
|
N/A
|
- ↑ repeated crashes in mutter
- ↑ not login in gdm
- ↑ lost when the system is the result of decreased
- ↑ segmentation failed
- ↑ not login in gdm
- ↑ Xorg started manualy from console
|
pda
|
HW
|
|
fail [2]
|
pass
|
pass
|
pass
|
fail [3]
|
warn [4]
|
|
N/A[6]
|
pass
|
fail [7]
|
N/A
|
03:00.0 VGA compatible controller: ATI Technologies Inc Device 689c
- ↑ RHBZ #678193
- ↑ No gnome-shell started. Only old gnome-panel.
- ↑ Only desktop wallpaper and infinite flashing mutter crash notice on second startx. No way to open Abrt.
- ↑ File:Renderchecklog radeon pda x86.gz
- ↑ RHBZ #679774
- ↑ Without gnome-shell there no fast user switching applet.
- ↑ Computer was sleep forever. (Until reset)
|
Ferry Huberts
|
HW
|
pass
|
pass
|
pass
|
pass
|
pass
|
pass
|
fail [1]
|
pass
|
pass
|
pass
|
pass
|
warn [2]
|
- ↑ can't upload file without being logged in
- ↑ after several plug/unplug actions dragging windows around is very slow. logging out and in again fixes it.
|
V99 Glu
|
HW
|
pass
|
pass
|
pass
|
pass [1]
|
pass
|
pass [2]
|
inprogress
|
pass
|
pass
|
pass [3]
|
fail [4]
|
N/A
|
- ↑ test passed, but "menu/Open" crashed totem (by the way, gedit, too)
- ↑ startx reports a lot of errors File:Testday-20110223-startx.log
- ↑ pulseaudio does not work correctly (muted) when I switch from graphical desktop to another one. If I switch from graphical desktop to any text mode console and then to another graphical desktop, then pulseaudio works rightly.
- ↑ First, "System menu/Suspend..." opens Shutdown dialog, second, about 10 seconds after pm-suspend system does power-off. After system powered-on display stays in standby mode. Only hard reset helps me.
|
Eric Blake
|
HW
|
[2]
|
inprogress
|
inprogress
|
inprogress
|
inprogress
|
inprogress
|
inprogress
|
inprogress
|
inprogress
|
inprogress
|
inprogress
|
N/A
|
01:00.0 VGA compatible controller [0300]: ATI Technologies Inc RV370 5B60 [Radeon X300 (PCIE)] [1002:5b60]
- ↑ RHBZ #679849
- ↑ keyboard and mouse lock up the moment gnome-shell starts
|
VM
|
warn [1] [2]
|
inprogress
|
inprogress
|
inprogress
|
inprogress
|
inprogress
|
inprogress
|
inprogress
|
inprogress
|
inprogress
|
inprogress
|
N/A
|
- ↑ into fallback mode
- ↑ encountered BZ 679826 while testing - control-center window is too large for 1024x768
|
Foppe[1][2]
|
HW
|
pass
|
pass
|
pass
|
pass [3]
|
pass
|
pass
|
warn [4]
|
pass [5]
|
pass
|
pass
|
pass [6]
|
warn [7][8]
|
3D_Pymol works nice.
- ↑ x86_64 live CD
- ↑ ATI mobility 5650/1Gb [1002:68c1]
- ↑ Can't move slider
- ↑ File:Renderchecklog 2011-02-23 foppe.gz 44 tests passed of 46 total
- ↑ 60.25 FPS
- ↑ Suspend from menu results in shutdown, close lid || suspend from shutdown menu OK
- ↑ startup results in clone /w wrong resolution. Disabling <-> enabling requires login. Once dualhead is activated it works as advertised.
- ↑ File:Xrandr 2011-02-23 foppe.gz
|
Cédric Olivier
|
HW
|
pass
|
inprogress
|
pass
|
inprogress
|
inprogress
|
inprogress
|
inprogress
|
inprogress
|
inprogress
|
inprogress
|
inprogress
|
N/A
|
|
Ostinru
|
HW
|
warn [1]
|
pass [2]
|
pass
|
pass
|
pass
|
N/A
|
warn [3]
|
pass [4]
|
pass
|
pass
|
pass
|
N/A
|
- ↑ when intel&radeon cards availibl livecd doesn't boot photo. When intel card disabled in BIOS livecd boot sucsesfully
- ↑ liveDVD loads in gnome2. gnome-shall --replace fix it
- ↑ 44/46 in gnome shall log
- ↑ 60FPS is too slow!
|
Ferry Huberts
|
HW
|
warn [1]
|
pass
|
pass
|
pass
|
pass
|
pass
|
warn [2]
|
pass
|
pass
|
pass
|
fail [3]
|
pass
|
- ↑ First boot I did from live CD resulted in the GNOME panel fallback. 'gnome-shell --replace' to get to the shell worked. Second boot logged in into gnome-shell ok.
- ↑ can't upload file without being logged in
- ↑ probably due to the areca raid card, that has always prevented suspend so far
|
Amir Hedayaty
|
HW
|
pass
|
pass
|
pass
|
pass
|
pass
|
pass
|
warn [1]
|
pass [2]
|
warn [3]
|
pass
|
pass
|
N/A
|
- ↑ File:Renderchecklog.gz 2124236 tests passed of 2124238 total
- ↑ In overview mode the frame rate drops dramaticly
- ↑ GDM does not work with any password! (I use automatic login to login) TODO: file a bug if it is not my own fault
|
Stephane Maniaci
|
HW
|
pass
|
pass
|
inprogress
|
inprogress
|
inprogress
|
inprogress
|
inprogress
|
inprogress
|
inprogress
|
inprogress
|
inprogress
|
inprogress
|
|
User
|
Smolt Profile
|
Basic test
|
GNOME 3 start
|
DPMS
|
XVideo
|
Rotation
|
X restart
|
Rendercheck
|
GLX
|
User switch
|
VT switch
|
Suspend
|
Multihead
|
Comments
|
Extended 3D tests