Test Day:2011-04-21 GNOME3 Final: Difference between revisions

Revision as of 12:37, 27 April 2011

Fedora Test Days

GNOME 3 (pre-F15 Final)

Date	2011-04-21
Time	all day

Website	http://www.gnome3.org
IRC	#fedora-test-day (webirc)
Mailing list	test

Can't make the date?
If you come to this page before or after the test day is completed, your testing is still valuable, and you can use the information on this page to test, file any bugs you find at GNOME Bugzilla, and add your results to the results section. If this page is more than a month old when you arrive here, please check the current schedule and see if a similar but more recent Test Day is planned or has already happened.

What to test?

Today's instalment of Fedora Test Day will focus on GNOME 3. This is the final of the three Fedora 15 Test Days focusing on GNOME 3. The goal of these events is to test as much as possible of the functionality of GNOME 3 to ensure that it works correctly and provides the necessary features for a day-to-day usable desktop.

Big changes ahead
Remember, this ain't your momma's GNOME - the overall user experience of GNOME 3 is very different from GNOME 2. It's fine to ask about the changes and make feature requests, but before filing a bug on something that's 'missing' from GNOME 2, please ask in #fedora-test-day to make sure it's not an intended change. There should always be someone there who can answer your question. Thanks!

Yay, 3.0 out!
This time, as GNOME 3 has been released recently, today's test day can provide a nice way for you to get familiar with the final version of the new desktop, its looks and all the important functionality - especially if you are new to it.

Who's available

The following cast of characters will be available for testing, workarounds, bug fixes, and general discussion ...

Development - Matthias Clasen (mclasen)
Quality Assurance - Adam Williamson (adamw), Vítězslav Humpa (vhumpa), Radek Lát (rlat)

Prerequisite for Test Day

An updated Fedora 15 pre-release, or the specific Test Day live image.
Your hardware profile uploaded to Smolt according to these instructions

For most testing, a graphics adapter capable of compositing: we are aiming to support all NVIDIA GeForce adapters, all Intel adapters except for GMA 500 (Poulsbo) and pre-i915 (i8xx) adapters, and all ATI/AMD Radeon adapters. If you are using an unsupported adapter, you can still help us with fallback testing - see below.

Unsupported adapters
Some adapters are known to be currently not working or problematic with the Shell. NVIDIA GeForce 400 series (Fermi / NVC0) adapters currently have no acceleration support and should fall back to compatibility mode (see the fallback testing section below). GeForce FX adapters may exhibit poor performance. Interaction may fail with GeForce 2 / GeForce 4 MX adapters, making the desktop effectively unusable.

Shell will not work in VirtualBox or virt-manager / KVM
Virtual machines without 3D acceleration pass-through support will not be suitable for most testing: the Shell will not run in these configurations. Also, even though some VirtualBox editions have passthrough support, the current Fedora implementation does not support it, so Shell will not work in VirtualBox either. If you are using a virtual machine, you can still help us with fallback testing - see below.

Also helpful, if you have or can get them:

Additional displays (monitors, TVs...)
As many storage devices as you can access
Optical media (burned, commercially pressed, and blank burnable, CDs, DVDs and Blu-Rays)
Wi-fi/bluetooth enabled networking devices
Graphics adapters, virtual machines, or driver configurations not capable of compositing, to test fallback support (see below)

How to test?

Live image

Verification
Please check the SHA256SUM is correct before booting!

You may download a non-destructive pre-Fedora 15 live image for your architecture. Tips on using a live image are available at FedoraLiveCD.

Architecture	SHA256SUM
i686	`9af0d24337a435d9c3f10fb34d1f16af7d6496b10ca0facf1a0630b45a66d544`
x86_64	`7d69f8324afc3de809144ff4104879c2240f3017e4db84cf5ed0d0259abb83e1`

Using the live image is the easiest way to participate in testing for most people, but alternatively you can:

Update your machine to Fedora 15

If you are already running or want to try the pre-release of Fedora 15, install Fedora 15 Beta and then update to the latest packages. Using the live image is easier and highly recommended.

Perform testing

Please perform as many of the test cases listed as you have the time and the resources to complete, and fill out your results in the table below. You do not need a Fedora account to fill in the table.

Network configuration problems
GNOME 3's network configuration interface is not yet feature complete and cannot handle some cases that GNOME 2's could. If a feature you need to set up your network is missing, use the nm-connection-editor tool. See this Common Bugs entry for more details.

Fallback testing

QA:Testcase_gnome3_fallback

This test case will test that GNOME falls back correctly to a 'classic' environment if your hardware does not support the GNOME Shell. If your hardware starts GNOME Shell correctly, please leave the fallback test column empty, and fill in the other test result columns. If your hardware is unable to start GNOME Shell, but falls back correctly to a classic environment, please mark the fallback test in the results table as 'pass', and leave the other test columns empty. If your hardware is unable to start GNOME Shell, and does not fall back correctly to a classic environment, please mark the fallback test in the results table as 'fail', file a bug against gnome-session, and leave the other test columns empty.

Regular tests

QA:Testcase_desktop_date
QA:Testcase_desktop_keyring
QA:Testcase_totem_basic
QA:Testcase_generic_video_multihead
QA:Testcase_desktop_uri NOTE: Use System Settings -> System Info -> Default Applications to configure your preferred applications
QA:Testcase_desktop_message_notification
QA:Testcase_gnome-shell_dash
QA:Testcase_gnome-shell_workspaces
QA:Testcase_gnome-shell_overview_search
QA:Testcase_desktop_login
QA:Testcase_gnome-terminal_profile
QA:Testcase_desktop_common_shortcuts
QA:Testcase_firefox_media

QA:Testcase_desktop_menus
QA:Testcase_gnome-bluetooth_send_file
QA:Testcase_firefox_browse
QA:Testcase_vino_vinagre_connect
QA:Testcase_gnome_desktop_background
QA:Testcase_desktop_non_gtk_apps
QA:Testcase_desktop_lock_screen
QA:Testcase_desktop_automount NOTE: there will is no file manager on the Desktop, see this mail for the design decision behind it
QA:Testcase_desktop_volume
QA:Testcase_evince_file_display
QA:Testcase_brasero_burn
QA:Testcase_generic_video_glx

Unplanned testing

As well as running the formal test cases, you can help simply by running GNOME 3 and reporting any problems you come across in the course of your typical use, even if they do not match up with any of the test cases. Please remember, though, that just being different from GNOME 2 is not necessarily a problem, and check in #fedora-test-day before you file a bug.

Test Results

If you have problems with any of the tests, try and report a bug. Most bugs in this event should be reported to GNOME Bugzilla. Bugs that are clearly issues in Fedora GNOME integration should be reported to Fedora Bugzilla. You will need an account to report bugs, but creating one is easy, and we will help you do this if you ask in IRC.

If you are not sure of the appropriate component, please check in IRC before filing, there are many possibilities. If you are unsure about exactly how to file the report or what other information to include, just ask on IRC and we will help you.

Once you have completed the tests, add your results to the Results table below, following the example results from the first line as a template. The first column should be your name with a link to your User page in the Wiki if you have one, and the second should be a link to the Smolt profile of the system you tested. For each test case, use the result template to describe your result, following the examples in the Sample user row.

User	Smolt Profile	Fallback	Date	Keyring	Totem	Multihead	URIs	Notification	Dash	Workspaces	Search	Login	Terminal	Shortcuts	References
Sample User	HW	none	pass	pass	pass	pass	pass	pass	pass	pass	pass	pass	warn ^[1]	fail ^[2]	↑ Test pass, but also encountered RHBZ #54321 ↑ RHBZ #12345
Andre Robatino	HW	pass	none	none	none	none	none	none	none	none	none	none	none	none
David Le Sage (Red Hat)	HW	pass	pass	warn ^[1]	none	warn ^[2]	pass	none	pass	fail ^[3]	pass	pass	fail ^[4]	pass	↑ Test pass, but abrt cannot save passwords: RHBZ #692340 ↑ Test pass for GNOME 3, but FWIW, KDE 4.6 cannot detect dual monitors. ↑ RHBZ #695222 RHBZ #695227 ↑ Making background transparent still doesn't work: RHBZ #683274
Tao Wu	HW	none	pass	pass	pass	none	pass	pass	pass	fail ^[1]	pass	pass	fail ^[2]	warn ^[3]	↑ RHBZ #698585 ↑ RHBZ #683274 ↑ The F1 shortcut doesn't work on my system: RHBZ #683274
Walter Justen	HW	none	pass	pass	pass	none	pass	pass	pass	pass	pass	pass	fail ^[1]	pass	↑ Making background transparent still doesn't work: RHBZ #683274
Pavol Celuch	HW	none	none	pass	pass	pass ^[1]	pass	pass	pass	fail ^[2]	pass	pass ^[3]	fail ^[4]	pass	↑ Test pass for GNOME 3. ↑ RHBZ #695222 ↑ RHBZ #680147 ↑ Transparent background doesn't work: RHBZ #683274
Nicolas Kaiser	HW	none	pass	pass	none	fail ^[1]	pass	pass ^[2]	pass	fail ^[3]	pass	none	fail ^[4]	pass	↑ RHBZ #698711 ↑ Creating a new jabber.org account failed with "network error". Connecting to an existing jabber.org account worked nicely. ↑ RHBZ #698585 ↑ RHBZ #681926, and 7. reverting settings doesn't reset colors
User:kenda	HW	none	fail ^[1]	none	pass	none	none	pass	pass	pass	pass	none	none	none	↑ Toggling 12/24h display doesn't change the panels clock display (filled as:RHBZ #698698)
Armin Preiml	HW	none	fail ^[1]	fail ^[2]	pass	none	fail ^[3]	pass	pass	fail ^[4]	pass	none	fail ^[5]	warn ^[6]	↑ NTP Doesn't work after switching on at gnome control center. ↑ Keyring didn't ask to store wireless network password. It didn't store the password of an encrypted external hd until logout ↑ Doesn't work with mailto in firefox ↑ RHBZ #698585 ↑ RHBZ #683274 ↑ Thinpad R60 Volume keys don't work
Scotty Delicious	HW	none	pass	pass	pass	none	pass	pass	pass	pass	pass	none	fail ^[1]	pass	↑ Transparency only in full screen and dash: RHBZ #683274 RHBZ #694682
Michal Hriň	HW	none	warn ^[1]	none	warn ^[2]	none	none	none	pass	warn ^[3]	pass	none	none	pass	↑ NTP On/Off button in gnome-control-centre does not remember it's position, every time on execution Date&Time settings is on On possition ↑ In "sunflower.webm" video don't work pause, rewind, it isn't smooth, video changes sides ratio, has grain and no sound, other tested videos works good ↑ During random random moving windows to workspaces reamined 2 empty workspaces and Firefox froze
Tim Flink	HW	none	warn ^[1]	pass	pass	none	pass	pass	pass ^[2]	pass	pass	pass	fail ^[3]	pass	↑ The date and time control panel in Gnome always turns NTP back on when I leave the panel and doesn't reflect time changes done from CLI, shell does, though ↑ had an unrelated crash ↑ RHBZ #681926
Marek Zdunek	HW	none	warn ^[1]	pass	pass	none	pass	fail ^[2]	pass	pass	pass	none	fail ^[3]	pass	↑ System settings => Date and time changing NTP completely not working, system-config-date works fine ↑ RHBZ #698148 Creating a new jabber.org account failed because of "network error" ↑ RHBZ #681926 RHBZ #683274 RHBZ #694682
Adam M Dutko	HW	pass ^[1]	fail ^[2]	pass	fail ^[3]	none	fail ^[4]	none	none	none	none	none	pass	pass	↑ Defaults to this because my vm doesn't support the shell. ↑ Setting the date manually, then disabling and reenabling ntp through the desktop date/time doesn't correct the time. The system-config-date utility sets the proper date after a manual set then enabling ntp. ↑ webm download doesn't fast forward or rewind using the slider bar. ↑ This works when I right click and choose "Open Link". Single left click does not work.
Marc Hollins	HW	none	fail ^[1]	pass	warn ^[2]	fail ^[3]	pass	fail ^[4]	pass	pass	pass	pass	fail ^[5]	pass	↑ Enabling NTP through the desktop doesn't correct the time. system-config-date was required to enter custom NTP servers, and actually start ntpd ↑ Scrubbing failed for the sunflower clip, was fine for the sintel clip. Ogg is fine. ↑ Did not detect Disconnect until running xrandr. Re-connect auto-detect was fine. ↑ Empathy does not work behind corporate proxy ↑ Encountered RHBZ #681926
Lukas Zapletal	HW	none	pass	pass ^[1]	pass ^[2]	pass	pass	pass	pass ^[3]	pass	pass ^[4]	none	pass	pass	↑ NetworkManager crash when trying passwords RHBZ #698807 ↑ but pause-rewind-start does not always work for the suflower.webm video ↑ Icon disappears when trying to rearrange on the dash RHBZ #698817 ↑ crash of Control Panel -> Keyboard, hard freeze when tried to report with ABRT
User:ergodic	[[1]]	none	pass	pass	none	pass	pass	pass	pass	pass	pass	pass	pass	pass
Pedro Fleck	HW	none	fail ^[1]	pass	pass	pass	none	pass	warn ^[2]	pass	pass	none	fail ^[3]	warn ^[4]	↑ To change time manually, you have to click 3 times in network time, and sometimes the time isn't keeped. ↑ Sometimes, in the applications, just appear the package manager. ↑ Making background transparent still doesn't work: RHBZ #683274 ↑ Test pass, but, in my notebook, the fn key don't work well, for example, I need the fn to press the F1, F2, etc. keys, but I can press it without the Fn, it makes the action keys (change volume, etc.) don't work well, too.
Leif Gruenwoldt	HW	none	none	none	none	fail ^[1]^[2]	none	none	none	none	none	none	none	none	↑ RHBZ #691620 ↑ RHBZ #698711
User:nocoast	HW	none	pass	pass	pass	none	pass	none	pass	pass	pass ^[1]	none	none	none	↑ Had to mount usb drive before it would be recognized for search
Amir Hedayaty	HW	none	warn ^[1]	none	pass	none	pass	pass	pass	pass ^[2]	pass	pass ^[3]	fail ^[4]	pass	↑ Setting to synchronize on-line is not working ideally, dis/enabling it on one tool if the other tool is open it will not notice ↑ Opening some apps like evolution opens some dialogue for authentication which is not opened at designated workspace ↑ Could not find anywhere to change keyboard layout! ↑ Transparency does not work, as other people have already mentioned, also reverting the color setting back to system does not do anything
sadam	HW	fail ^[1]	none	none	none	none	none	none	none	none	none	none	none	none	↑ It worked only 1/10 reboots. 9/10 it was unusable.
Dan Dragomir	HW	none	warn ^[1] ^[2]	none	pass	warn ^[3] ^[4]	none	none	none	none	none	none	none	none	↑ NTP doesn't work when enabling in gnome control center; it works from system-config-date. ↑ When changing the time from gnome control center the desktop panel takes a long time to update and it does this in increments of 1. If one minute passes while the desktop panel is updating, the time in gnome control center changes to what the panel showed when the minute passed, although the panel keeps updating towards the orignial time set in the control center ↑ Disabling the laptop display changes the resolution of the secondary display, but only when the desktop panel is placed on the laptop display; the new resolution is not reflected in the shown configuration; the resolution can be fixed manually by temporarly selecting a new resolution for the seconday display ↑ Arranging the displays is limited when one of them is disabled
Tadej Janež	HW	none	warn ^[1]	fail ^[2]	warn ^[3]	none	fail ^[4]	pass	warn ^[5]	fail ^[6]	pass	fail ^[7]	fail ^[8]	pass ^[9]	↑ Date and Time application doesn't correctly control the ntpd service GNOME #648556 ↑ Keyring didn't ask to store the wireless network password. ↑ The WebM test with "sunflower.webm" video didn't pause, rewind or seek. The "sintel-360p.webm" video and OGG Theora test video worked ok. ↑ Firefox doesn't respect the desktop's default URI handlers in GNOME 3: RHBZ #699359. System Info -> Default Applications doesn't remember the changes GNOME #648599. ↑ The 'New Window' behaviour is inconsistent: e.g. for Firefox, Epiphany and Nautilus it opens a new window. It even opens a new window for Deja Dup. For Rhythmbox, gedit, Disk Utility, it doesn't open a new window. ↑ As others noted: RHBZ #698585. ↑ The system doesn't remember keyboard layout settings: GNOME #648748. Also, gdm 3.0.0 doesn't display the currently active keyboard layout and it doesn't offer an option to change it: GNOME #648749. ↑ As others noted: transparency does not work: RHBZ #681926. Also, reverting the color settings back to system theme doesn't do anything ↑ It would be nice and consistent if Firefox also brought up the Help if one presses F1
Jeff Sandys	HW	Fallback	Date	Keyring	Totem	Multihead	URIs	Notification	Dash	Workspaces	Search	Login	Terminal	Shortcuts	Tests in progress
User	Smolt Profile	Fallback	Date	Keyring	Totem	Multihead	URIs	Notification	Dash	Workspaces	Search	Login	Terminal	Shortcuts	References

User	Smolt Profile	Web media	Menus	Bluetooth	Browse	VNC	Background	NonGtk	Lock	Mount	Volume	Evince	Burn	GL	References
Sample User	HW	pass	pass	pass	pass	pass	pass	pass	pass	pass	pass	pass	warn ^[1]	fail ^[2]	↑ Test pass, but also encountered RHBZ #54321 ↑ RHBZ #12345
David Le Sage (Red Hat)	HW	pass	pass	none	pass	none	pass	pass	pass	pass	pass	pass	none	none
Tao Wu	HW	pass	pass	none	pass	none	pass	none	pass	none	none	none	none	none
Walter Justen	HW	pass	pass	none	pass	none	pass	pass	warn ^[1]	pass	pass	pass	none	none	↑ Doesn't lock the screen after set interval
Pavol Celuch	HW	pass	pass ^[1]	fail ^[2]	pass	none	pass	pass	warn ^[3]	pass	pass	pass	none	pass	↑ system-config-authentication icon is fuzzy RHBZ #698244 ↑ RHBZ #698556 ↑ Doesn't lock the screen after set interval
Nicolas Kaiser	HW	none	none	none	pass	none	pass	none	none	none	pass	pass	none	pass
Armin Preiml	HW	pass	none	pass	pass	none	pass	none	none	warn ^[1]	pass	pass	none	pass	↑ Volume Keys on Thinkpad work independently of gnomes volume control.
Scotty Delicious	HW	pass	warn ^[1]	pass	pass	none	pass ^[2]	warn ^[3]	pass	pass	pass	pass	pass ^[4]	pass	↑ Menu test seems to refer to Gnome 2.x UI elements ↑ Can change background, but Background test refers to Gnome 2.x UI elements ↑ Tested using smolt-gui and k9copy. Most UI elements match Gtk, but icons are clearly Oxygen (very shiny/glassy/2005 ugly) ↑ Did not test blanking rw media.
Michal Hriň	HW	pass	none	none	pass	none	warn ^[1]	warn ^[2]	fail ^[3]	none	pass	pass	none	none	↑ No control element for control how had to be showed bigger image than my resolution on background ↑ (LiveCD)First time installation of testing apps froze hole computer, second time OK, in freemind doesnt work context menu ↑ Menu in gnome-control centre is grayed/disabled
Adam M Dutko	HW	pass	none	none	pass	pass ^[1]	none	none	none	pass ^[2]	none	pass	none	none	↑ RHEL6 (vino) and F15b (vinagre) ↑ T-Mobile G1 SD Card
ergodic	[[2]]	pass	pass	none	pass	none	pass	none	none	pass	pass	pass	pass	pass
Amir Hedayaty	HW	pass	pass	none	pass	none	warn ^[1]	pass	pass	pass	pass	pass ^[2]	fail ^[3]	pass	↑ Tiling does not work ↑ Annotations quite buggy ↑ RHBZ #699023
Tadej Janež	HW	pass	fail ^[1]	none	pass	fail ^[2]	none	none	none	none	none	none	none	none	↑ As mentioned before, the icon for system-config-authentication is fuzzy. Also, the test case instructions should be updated to reflect the new Application selector in GNOME 3 (without the menus). There is the Other category, which is not empty: RHBZ #699422 ↑ I was only able to test VNC against a remote machine that uses SSH tunneling for VNC remote access. Vinagre failed the same way as older versions in F13 and F14: RHBZ #645913
User	Smolt Profile	Web media	Menus	Bluetooth	Browse	VNC	Background	NonGtk	Lock	Mount	Volume	Evince	Burn	GL	References

[1] Test pass, but also encountered RHBZ #54321

[2] RHBZ #12345

[3] Test pass, but abrt cannot save passwords: RHBZ #692340

[4] Test pass for GNOME 3, but FWIW, KDE 4.6 cannot detect dual monitors.

[5] RHBZ #695222 RHBZ #695227

[6] Making background transparent still doesn't work: RHBZ #683274

[7] RHBZ #698585

[8] RHBZ #683274

[9] The F1 shortcut doesn't work on my system: RHBZ #683274

[10] Making background transparent still doesn't work: RHBZ #683274

[11] Test pass for GNOME 3.

[12] RHBZ #695222

[13] RHBZ #680147

[14] Transparent background doesn't work: RHBZ #683274

[15] RHBZ #698711

[16] Creating a new jabber.org account failed with "network error". Connecting to an existing jabber.org account worked nicely.

[17] RHBZ #698585

[18] RHBZ #681926, and 7. reverting settings doesn't reset colors

[19] Toggling 12/24h display doesn't change the panels clock display (filled as:RHBZ #698698)

[20] NTP Doesn't work after switching on at gnome control center.

[21] Keyring didn't ask to store wireless network password. It didn't store the password of an encrypted external hd until logout

[22] Doesn't work with mailto in firefox

[23] RHBZ #698585

[24] RHBZ #683274

[25] Thinpad R60 Volume keys don't work

[26] Transparency only in full screen and dash: RHBZ #683274 RHBZ #694682

[27] NTP On/Off button in gnome-control-centre does not remember it's position, every time on execution Date&Time settings is on On possition

[28] In "sunflower.webm" video don't work pause, rewind, it isn't smooth, video changes sides ratio, has grain and no sound, other tested videos works good

[29] During random random moving windows to workspaces reamined 2 empty workspaces and Firefox froze

[1]

[2]

[1]

[2]

[3]

[4]

[1]

[2]

[3]

[1]

[1]

[2]

[3]

[4]

[1]

[2]

[3]

[4]

[1]

[1]

[2]

[3]

[4]

[5]

[6]

[1]

[1]

[2]

[3]

[1]

[2]

[3]

[1]

[2]

[3]

[1]

[2]

[3]

[4]

[1]

[2]

[3]

[4]

[5]

[1]

[2]

[3]

[4]

[1]

[2]

[3]

[4]

[1]

[2]

[1]

[1]

[2]

[3]

[4]

[1]

[1]

[2]

[3]

[4]

[1]

[2]

[3]

[4]

[5]

[6]

[7]

[8]

[9]

[1]

[2]

[1]

[1]

[2]

[3]

[1]

[1]

[2]

[3]

[4]

[1]

[2]

[3]

[1]

[2]

[1]

[2]

[3]

[1]

[2]

@@ Line 831: / Line 831: @@
 | {{result|none}}
 | {{result|pass}}
-| {{result|none}}
+| {{result|fail}} <ref> I was only able to test VNC against a remote machine that uses SSH tunneling for VNC remote access. Vinagre failed the same way as older versions in F13 and F14: {{bz|645913}} </ref>
 | {{result|none}}
 | {{result|none}}

Search