Features/PackageSignatureCheckingDuringOSInstall

Package Signature Checking During OS Installation

Summary

One long-standing problem in Fedora is that we don't check package signatures during initial operating system installation. This has been a persistent issue since the very beginning of Fedora (and even in Red Hat Linux before it.) The reason for this has always been that there's no way to form any root of trust for the signatures in the repositories, and thus no reason they wouldn't have been modified along with whatever package would need to be re-signed after tampering.

Following the implementation of Features/SecureBoot, we can extend the Secure Boot keys as a root of trust provided by the hardware against which we can verify a signature on our key files, thus guaranteeing that they're from the same source as the boot media.

With this scheme, a repo would provide a signed file containing their signing keys, which we would verify and import on a per-repo basis. It will still be possibly to manually add repos not participating in the signature scheme, though it will require manual intervention during installation.

Owner

• Name: Peter Jones

Current status

• Targeted release: Fedora 19
• Last updated: 2013-01-02
• Percentage of completion: 5%

Sub-task	Percent Complete	Owner	Notes
kexec	?	vgoyal	need verification of static binaries so we can be sure peverify is real
peverify	50	pjones	need to finish it.
fedora-release	0	pjones	2 things here - 1) must be moved to "secure-boot" koji channel, 2) must be modified to provide a signed set of keys
anaconda	0	pjones	needs to detect that we're in a secure-boot environment and, if so, enforce signature checking on keys and packages.

Benefit to Fedora

Allows verification of packages during installation.

Scope

See the table at Features/PackageSignatureCheckingDuringOSInstall#Current_status

Test Plan

UEFI-capable systems with Secure Boot features are available from most vendors.

The test methodology is simple - enable secure boot, create a repo with an unsigned package in it, do an install that includes that package. Installation should fail.

User Experience

Significantly similar to that of today in most cases.

Dependencies

• peverify being trusted is probably dependent on vgoyal's work for kexec+secureboot.
• "repo" in kickstart (pykickstart, anaconda) may change to specify an enforcement policy.
• There may be additional work needed to add enforcement policy on a per-repo basis to repomd.xml.

Contingency Plan

• Bump this to a later release.

Documentation

• http://www.uefi.org
• https://www.tianocore.org/
• http://msdn.microsoft.com/en-us/library/windows/hardware/jj128256

Release Notes

With this release, package signatures will be checked by default during installation on compatible hardware.

Comments and Discussion

• See Talk:Features/PackageSignatureCheckingDuringInstall