(→Lapland is not a good idea: new section) |
(→Lovelock -- Beefy Miracle link: new section) |
||
| Line 10: | Line 10: | ||
I'm not against using a Sámi theme in Fedora, just don't mess up the naming :) | I'm not against using a Sámi theme in Fedora, just don't mess up the naming :) | ||
== Lovelock -- Beefy Miracle link == | |||
Is the proposed algorithm really a suitable link? As the result of the [http://wordshack.wordpress.com/2011/03/03/namethatrelease/#comment-303 Algorithm] can only be a single digit between 1 (not 0, unless the empty string is a permissible release name) and 9, about 11% of the words in the dictionary will fit this link. AFAIK, links like "are both 8 letter words" are unwelcome, although the hit rate would only be marginally higher ([http://www.google.com/url?sa=t&source=web&cd=8&sqi=2&ved=0CFsQFjAH&url=http%3A%2F%2Flinkinghub.elsevier.com%2Fretrieve%2Fpii%2F0378375886901692&rct=j&q=english%20word%20length%20distribution&ei=xpiDTY_ZLsmE0QGm1MSRDQ&usg=AFQjCNEf4dSTdgeL0OS5asYwOLZEuUvOww&cad=rja Rothschild] states that around 12 % of the entries of an English dictionary were eight letter words. In actual usage, only fewer than 6 % of the words have 8 letters). So why then are results of the algorithm "Count the number of letters" rejected, while the results of this one are not? --[[User:Pbro|Pbro]] 17:51, 18 March 2011 (UTC) | |||
Latest revision as of 17:51, 18 March 2011
I had suggested "Eufaula" as an F16 name because Lovelock and Eufaula are both names of US towns that have restaurants called the Cowpoke Cafe.
However, I have just learned that the name Eufaula originates as a Native American tribe name (see http://www.accessgenealogy.com/native/creek/early-history/eufaula_tribe.htm). The tradition established by Apache, and continued by Cherokee and Hiawatha, of naming web server projects after Native American tribes (or, in the case of Hiawatha, prominent historical or legendary Native American leaders) is at least arguably problematic, and I have raised specific objections to the logo in use by the Cherokee project (https://bugzilla.redhat.com/show_bug.cgi?id=681339) (objections that are even more applicable to Hiawatha). I believe it would at least have the appearance of inconsistency and hypocrisy for me to support (or even to make it possible for others to support) the choice of "Eufaula" as a name for Fedora 16, however innocent the suggestion was. Therefore, I respectfully withdraw my suggestion. Accordingly, I have removed the entry from the table of name suggestions.
- Richard Fontana
Lapland is not a good idea
In Norway "Lapp" is considered a bad term for the Sámi people and "Lappland" is a deprecated term for the area they (traditionally) live(d) in (it's now called Sameland or Sápmi). I'm not sure how true this is in Sweden and Finland where Lappland formally refers to areas in their countries …
I'm not against using a Sámi theme in Fedora, just don't mess up the naming :)
Lovelock -- Beefy Miracle link
Is the proposed algorithm really a suitable link? As the result of the Algorithm can only be a single digit between 1 (not 0, unless the empty string is a permissible release name) and 9, about 11% of the words in the dictionary will fit this link. AFAIK, links like "are both 8 letter words" are unwelcome, although the hit rate would only be marginally higher (Rothschild states that around 12 % of the entries of an English dictionary were eight letter words. In actual usage, only fewer than 6 % of the words have 8 letters). So why then are results of the algorithm "Count the number of letters" rejected, while the results of this one are not? --Pbro 17:51, 18 March 2011 (UTC)