QA/Meetings/20110516

Attendees

People present (lines said):

1. jlaska (151)
2. adamw (56)
3. kparal (28)
4. j_dulaney (21)
5. brunowolff (16)
6. tflink (14)
7. vhumpa (12)
8. pbrobinson (9)
9. jsmith (5)
10. Southern_Gentlem (4)
11. rbergeron (3)
12. satellit_ (3)
13. fenrus02 (1)
14. elad661 (1)
15. Viking-Ice (1)
16. msavy (1)

Unable to attend:

1. Rhe (hopefully sleeping)
2. Hongqing (hopefully sleeping)
3. wutao85 (hopefully sleeping)
4. jskladan

Agenda

• Proposed meeting agenda
• MeetBot summary

Previous meeting follow-up

1. tflink to follow-up with cloud sig for test day recap
   • mgoldmann or msavy will follow-up this week (conferences previous 2 weeks)
2. jlaska to follow-up w/ halfline on bug#702650, kparal+jlaska to verify
   • Appears to be tested and resolved, thanks kparal and halfline
3. adamw proposing patch for bug#697834
   • Done ... AcceptedNTH and available for walters if desired
4. jlaska - file proposed NTH bugs for F14->F15
   • Done

F-15-Final-RC3 status

• STATUS: INPROGRESS - Tuesday, May 17
• Continue to monitor for blocker bugs at https://fedoraproject.org/wiki/Current_Release_Blockers
• Thank you Robatino for the RC3 announcement and wiki management
• Robatino already created Final RC1 QA wiki pages at https://fedoraproject.org/wiki/Category:Fedora_15_Final_RC_Test_Results
• The team conducted a *mini* review of 4 proposed blocker bugs ...
  1. RHBZ #704726 - gnome-desktop3 - upgrade from F-14 broken due to conflicts with gnome-desktop
     • AGREED: tentatively agree to keep on list awaiting additional feedback from reporter. If conditions hold, likely not a blocker since yum upgrades are not the official upgrade mechanism
  2. RHBZ #704727 - gnome-themes-standard - upgrade from F-14 broken due to conflicts with gnome-themes
     • AGREED: tentatively agree to keep on list awaiting additional feedback from reporter. If conditions hold, likely not a blocker since yum upgrades are not the official upgrade mechanism
  3. RHBZ #704729 - gobject-introspection - upgrade from F-14 broken due to conflicts with dbus-glib
     • AGREED: tentatively agree to keep on list awaiting additional feedback from reporter. If conditions hold, likely not a blocker since yum upgrades are not the official upgrade mechanism
  4. RHBZ #704728 - polkit - upgrade from F-14 broken due to conflicts with polkit-desktop-policy
     • AGREED: tentatively agree to keep on list awaiting additional feedback from reporter. If conditions hold, likely not a blocker since yum upgrades are not the official upgrade mechanism
• And 3 proposed NTH bugs ...
  1. RHBZ #704188 - anaconda - TypeError: 'NoneType' object is not subscriptable
     • AGREED: AcceptedNTH
  2. RHBZ #704020 - gnome-panel - libpanel_applet changed ABI; not all applets ported
     • AGREED: RejectedNTH - Yum upgrades not officially supported, day-0 update acceptable.
  3. RHBZ #703944 - pfstools - pfstools-octave has broken dependencies.
     • AGREED: RejectedNTH - Yum upgrades not officially supported, day-0 update acceptable.

AutoQA update

• kparal implemented package caching in AutoQA (optional, default off). When enabled, it drastically speeds up mainly depcheck runs.
• jskladan introduced an algorithm to filter interesting information from depcheck log about why a particular package has broken dependencies
• we started to nicely document our test cases. First piece is upgradepath (see https://fedoraproject.org/wiki/AutoQA_tests/Upgradepath)
• tflink worked on issue of yum getting stuck in a loop that generated huge depcheck logs. When new yum builds land in stable repos, we should be have that handled. Tflink also noted the updates are still in 'updates-testing', pending additional positive karma.
• vhumpa created a pretty text template for our future test reports (see http://vhumpa.fedorapeople.org/prettylog_upgradepath_example2.txt)
• Jlaska reported that the log size issue appears under control. Compressing logs > 100M every 2 hours

Upcoming QA events

1. Tuesday, May 17 - Go/NoGo meeting
2. Tuesday, May 24 - Final (GA) release