BITCOIN: Difference between revisions

Revision as of 03:50, 30 October 2015

There probably should be two separate SELinux policy modules for the two different ways Bitcoin Core is used.

User service bitcoind and graphical bitcoin-qt
- The most common way to use Bitcoin Core is users run their own bitcoind or bitcoin-qt as a non-root user with datadir ~/.bitcoin/.
- There should be a separate user homedir SELinux policy for bitcoind and bitcoin-qt operated in this manner, with a context like user_bitcoin_t.
  - Note: Arbitrary other services may need to be granted both UNIX filesystem and SELinux permission to read the autotoken file from the user's ~/.bitcoin directory.
System Service bitcoind
- bitcoind is not normally used as a system service but people want it to be packaged in this way. Perhaps this should be a sub-package like bitcoin-system-service. It would contain only the .service file, config, and README's.
- Should have its datadir somewhere like %{_datadir}bitcoinsys/ which expands to /var/lib/bitcoinsys/
- Config file %config(noreplace) %{_datadir}/bitcoinsys/bitcoin.conf with wallet disabled by default, but they could enable it with wallet=1 if they really want it.
- With system username like: bitcoinsys
- Wrapper should launch bitcoind in a context named like: bitcoinsys_t
- %doc README-FEDORA-BITCOIN-SERVICE should probably explain how the service is meant to be configured, used and controlled with bitcoin-cli or RPC/REST interfaces as the non-default datadir does not match upstream documentation and it thus may be non-obvious to users.

Build Determinism/Reproducible Builds: Given identical inputs of source code and N-V-R's of dependencies in the buildroot, the binary output packaged must be identical when built by anyone.
- In this way anyone can verify that the binaries built on the Fedora buildsystem are not different from what should have been built from that source code. This allows for improved assurance that the build is not compromised.
Medium-term goal: Also modify the .spec's of all library dependencies to make their builds reproducible.

@@ Line 10: / Line 10: @@
 *** Note: Arbitrary other services may need to be granted both UNIX filesystem and SELinux permission to read the autotoken file from the user's ~/.bitcoin directory.
 * '''System Service bitcoind'''
-** bitcoind is not normally used as a system service but people want it to be packaged in this way.  Perhaps this should be a sub-package like bitcoin-system-service.  It would contain only the .service file, config, and README's.
+** bitcoind is not normally used as a system service but people want it to be packaged in this way.  Perhaps this should be a sub-package like <code>bitcoin-system-service</code>.  It would contain only the .service file, config, and README's.
 ** Should have its datadir somewhere like %{_datadir}bitcoinsys/ which expands to /var/lib/bitcoinsys/
 ** Config file <code>%config(noreplace) %{_datadir}/bitcoinsys/bitcoin.conf</code> with wallet disabled by default, but they could enable it with wallet=1 if they really want it.