Hash algorithm migration status

Notes

This page currently tracks the migration status of selected packages to SHA-256 as part of the StrongerHashes feature.

To Do

These packages use or refer to hashes from which we should migrate away. Being on this list does not yet mean the package will have to change: another manual check is necessary. You can see the known hash uses at http://people.redhat.com/mitr/hashes/found-hashes .

Necessary for system integrity

Package	Description	Notes
krb5	The Kerberos network authentication system.	See #krb5 for configuration. GSS-API v1 hard-codes MD5, would need v2 (RFC4121). pkinit hard-codes SHA-1 preauth "SAM" hard-codes MD5. pbkdf2 hard-codes HMAC-SHA1.
kernel	The Linux kernel	sunrpc auth_gss krb5 uses GSS-API v1, hard-codes DES_MAC_MD5 (GSS-API v2 would be necessary for stronger hashes). sunrpc auth_gss spkm3 hard-codes HMAC-MD5 (HMAC-SHA1 is not requried by RFC2847). ecryptfs uses MD5 to generate IVs for block encryption. ecryptfs supports only MD5 in string-to-key algorithm for PGP private key handling. sctp cookie used when opening a connection uses a HMAC, kernel is configured to use a MD5 HMAC (#485933). reiserfs, ext3, ext4 hashed directories use various hashes, collisions are handled. sctp packet authentication uses a SHA-1 or SHA-256 HMAC. TCPOPT_MD5SIG (RFC2385) uses MD5 of a packet and a shared key; there's no space for a larger hash in the header, and if changes are made, IPSec can be used instead. TCP syncookies are generated using a SHA-1 block transform, probably limited more by output size than the hash. IPSec digest supports SHA-1 and SHA-256 HMAC. modversions use MD4 to compute MODULE_INFO(srcversion): not intended to use as a cryptographic proof - anyone can simply overwrite the field in the compiled module. CIFS uses MD4 and MD5 for authentication (NTLM, NTLMv2), MD5 for packet signatures, MD5 in (unimplemented) MacOS symlinks. PPP MPPE uses SHA-1 (RFC3078, RFC3079). random.c uses SHA-1 for generating random numbers. random.c uses MD4 for generating IP IDs, TCP ISNs and similar numbers (based on a periodically changing secret). drivers/staging/rt28{6,7}0 use MD5 and SHA-1 HMAC in various wireless protocol implementations. jbd2 has a checksum field and defines MD5 and SHA-1 identifiers, but only implements CRC32. nfsd differentiates between different clients using cl_recdir, a MD5 of the client's real client id, and does not handle collisions, but any DoS that can be created by generating collision can be just as easily created by duplicating the real client id directly.
pam	An extensible library which provides authentication for applications	pam_unix uses MD5 to store passwords in opasswd (#487298). pam_namespace may use MD5 of user name or SELinux context in a directory name (#487302). pam_unix password verification handles MD5 inside the module, uses crypt() for others. pam_unix uses MD5 to generate a random salt. pam_timestamp uses SHA-1 HMAC to authenticate timestamp files.
pam_ccreds	Pam module to cache login credentials	Uses SHA1(known data, password) to store passwords (#487306).
yp-tools	NIS (or YP) client programs.	yppasswd will replace SHA-2 hashes with a DES hash (#487607).
cryptsetup-luks	A utility for setting up encrypted filesystems
db4	The Berkeley DB database library (version 4) for C
e2fsprogs	Utilities for managing the second and third extended (ext2/ext3) filesystems
grub	Grand Unified Boot Loader
initscripts	The inittab file and the /etc/init.d scripts
iptables	Tools for managing Linux kernel packet filtering capabilities
mdadm	The mdadm program controls Linux md devices (software RAID arrays)
module-init-tools	Kernel module management utilities.
policycoreutils	SELinux policy core utilities
sysvinit	Programs which control basic system processes
gnupg2	Utility for secure communication and data storage
rsyslog	Enhanced system logging and kernel message trapping daemons
esc	Enterprise Security Client Smart Card Client
gdm	The GNOME Display Manager
xorg-x11-server	X.Org X11 X server
anaconda	Graphical system installer
booty	simple python bootloader config lib
cluster	Red Hat Cluster
clustermon	Monitoring and management of Red Hat Enterprise Linux Cluster Suite
createrepo	Creates a common metadata repository
crypto-utils	SSL certificate and key management utilities
ecryptfs-utils	The eCryptfs mount helper and support libraries
gnome-keyring	Framework for managing passwords and other secrets
kexec-tools	The kexec/kdump userspace component.
PackageKit	Package management service
trousers	TCG's Software Stack v1.2

Servers

Package	Description	Notes
bind	The Berkeley Internet Name Domain (BIND) DNS (Domain Name System) server
cups	Common Unix Printing System
cvs	A version control system
cyrus-sasl	The Cyrus SASL library
dhcp	Dynamic host configuration protocol software
gnutls	A TLS protocol implementation
ipsec-tools	Tools for configuring and using IPSEC
libgcrypt	A general-purpose cryptography library
m2crypto	Support for using OpenSSL in python scripts
nc	Reads and writes data across network connections using TCP or UDP
nfs-utils	NFS utilities and supporting clients and daemons for the kernel NFS server
nss	Network Security Services
openldap	LDAP support libraries
openssh	An open source implementation of SSH protocol versions 1 and 2
openssl	A general purpose cryptography library with TLS implementation
postfix	Postfix Mail Transport Agent
ppp	The PPP (Point-to-Point Protocol) daemon.
rsync	A program for synchronizing files over a network
stunnel	An SSL-encrypting socket wrapper
apr	Apache Portable Runtime library
apr-util	Apache Portable Runtime Utility library
authd	A RFC 1413 ident protocol daemon
axis	A SOAP implementation in Java
dovecot	Dovecot Secure imap server
exim	The exim mail transfer agent
freeipmi	IPMI remote console and system management software
freeradius	High-performance and highly configurable free RADIUS server
gnome-user-share	Gnome user file sharing
htdig	ht://Dig - Web search engine
httpd	Apache HTTP Server
jetty	The Jetty Webserver and Servlet Container
libntlm	NTLM authentication library
mailman	Mailing list manager with built in Web access
mod_auth_mysql	Basic authentication for the Apache web server using a MySQL database
mod_auth_pgsql	Basic authentication for the Apache HTTP Server using a PostgreSQL database
ntp	The NTP daemon and utilities
openswan	Openswan IPSEC implementation
postgresql	PostgreSQL client programs and libraries	MD5 is used to save encrypted passwords (SQL: ALTER USER ... WITH ENCRYPTED PASSWORD ...). MD5 is also used for client autentization. Username is used as the salt for the hash, there are no stronger methods to store password or autenticate.
samba	The Samba Suite of programs
scsi-target-utils	The SCSI target daemon and utility programs
sendmail	A widely used Mail Transport Agent (MTA)
squid	The Squid proxy caching server
squirrelmail	SquirrelMail webmail client
struts	Web application framework
subversion	Modern Version Control System designed to replace CVS
tomcat5	Apache Servlet/JSP Engine, RI for Servlet 2.4/JSP 2.0 API
mod_perl	An embedded Perl interpreter for the Apache HTTP Server
mod_python	An embedded Python interpreter for the Apache HTTP Server

Untrusted data handling

Package	Description	Notes
curl	A utility for getting files from remote servers (FTP, HTTP, and others)
elinks	A text-mode Web browser
ghostscript	A PostScript(TM) interpreter and renderer.
lftp	A sophisticated file transfer program
mailx	Enhanced implementation of the mailx command
net-snmp	A collection of SNMP protocol tools and libraries
NetworkManager	Network connection manager and user applications
python-urlgrabber	A high-level cross-protocol url-grabber
rp-pppoe	A PPP over Ethernet client (for xDSL support).
sos	A set of tools to gather troubleshooting information from a system
tcpdump	A network traffic monitoring tool
telnet	The client program for the telnet remote login protocol.
wget	A utility for retrieving files using the HTTP or FTP protocols
wpa_supplicant	WPA/WPA2/IEEE 802.1X Supplicant
binutils	A GNU collection of binary utilities
elfutils	A collection of utilities and DSOs to handle compiled objects
fontconfig	Font configuration and customization library
gcc	Various compilers (C, C++, Objective-C, Java, ...)
glib2	A library of handy utility functions
ksh	The Original ATT Korn Shell
man	A set of documentation tools: man, apropos and whatis
OpenIPMI	IPMI (Intelligent Platform Management Interface) library and tools
perl	Practical Extraction and Report Language
perl-Digest-HMAC	Digest-HMAC Perl module
perl-Digest-SHA1	Digest-SHA1 Perl module
prelink	An ELF prelinking utility
python	An interpreted, interactive, object-oriented programming language
python-sqlite2	DB-API 2.0 interface for SQLite 3.x
rhpl	Library of Python code used by installation and configuration tools
sqlite	Library that implements an embeddable SQL database engine
system-config-network	The GUI of the Network Adminstration Tool
util-linux-ng	A collection of basic system utilities
cadaver	Command-line WebDAV client
clucene	A C++ port of Lucene
dirmngr	Client for Managing/Downloading CRLs
empathy	Instant Messaging Client for GNOME
evolution	Mail and calendar client for GNOME
evolution-data-server	Backend data server for Evolution
firefox	Mozilla Firefox Web browser
flac	An encoder/decoder for the Free Lossless Audio Codec
gftp	A multi-threaded FTP client for the X Window System
gnome-pilot-conduits	Additional conduits for gnome-pilot
gpgme	GnuPG Made Easy - high level crypto API
gstreamer-plugins-base	GStreamer streaming media framework base plug-ins
gstreamer-plugins-good	GStreamer plug-ins with good code and licensing
gvfs	Backends for the gio framework in GLib
iscsi-initiator-utils	iSCSI daemon and utility programs
jakarta-commons-httpclient	Jakarta Commons HTTPClient implements the client side of HTTP standards
jpilot	Jpilot pilot desktop software
jsch	Pure Java implementation of SSH2
jss	Java Security Services (JSS)
libdvdread	A library for reading DVD video discs based on Ogle code
libgadu	A Gadu-gadu protocol compatible communications library
libggz	Library for client-server games
libgpod	Library to access the contents of an iPod
libksba	X.509 library
libmsn	Library for connecting to the MSN Messenger service
libmusicbrainz	Library for accessing MusicBrainz servers
libotr	Off-The-Record Messaging library and toolkit
libprelude	The prelude library
libsilc	SILC Client Library
libsoup	Soup, an HTTP library implementation
libssh2	A library implementing the SSH2 protocol
lucene	High-performance, full-featured text search engine
mrtg	Multi Router Traffic Grapher
mutt	A text mode mail user agent
mysql	MySQL client programs and shared libraries
neon	An HTTP and WebDAV client library
nmap	Network exploration tool and security scanner
openoffice.org	OpenOffice.org comprehensive office suite.
perl-Net-DNS	DNS resolver modules for Perl
perl-Net-SNMP	Object oriented interface to SNMP
pidgin	A Gtk+ based multiprotocol instant messaging client
pilot-link	File transfer utilities between Linux and PalmPilots
poppler	PDF rendering library
postgresql-jdbc	JDBC driver for PostgreSQL
postgresql-odbc	PostgreSQL ODBC driver
pygpgme	Python module for working with OpenPGP messages
python-ldap	An object-oriented API to access LDAP directory servers
rdesktop	X client for remote desktop into Windows Terminal Server
rhythmbox	Music Management Application
spamassassin	Spam filter for email which can be invoked from mail delivery agents
spambayes	Bayesian anti-spam filter
strigi	A desktop search program for KDE
thunderbird	Mozilla Thunderbird mail/newsgroup client
totem	Movie player for GNOME
wavpack	A completely open audiocodec
WebKit	Web content engine library
wireshark	Network traffic analyzer
xine-lib	A multimedia engine
xmlsec1	Library providing support for ""XML Signature"" and ""XML Encryption"" standards
xulrunner	XUL Runtime for Gecko Applications

General

Package	Description	Notes
ant	Ant build tool for java
arts	aRts (analog realtime synthesizer) - the KDE sound system
boost	The Boost C++ Libraries
bug-buddy	Crash reporting utility for the GNOME desktop
cdrkit	A collection of CD/DVD utilities
classpathx-mail	GNU JavaMail(tm)
cmake	Cross-platform make system
corosync	The Corosync Cluster Engine and Application Programming Interfaces
doxygen	A documentation system for C/C++.
eclipse	An open, extensible IDE
eet	Library for speedy data storage, retrieval, and compression
emacs	GNU Emacs text editor
exempi	Library for easy parsing of XMP metadata
exiv2	Exif and Iptc metadata manipulation library
fftw	Fast Fourier Transform library
gdb	A GNU source-level debugger for C, C++, Java and other languages
gedit	Text editor for the GNOME desktop
geronimo-specs	Geronimo J2EE server J2EE specifications
gimp	GNU Image Manipulation Program
glibmm24	C++ interface for GTK2 (a GUI library for X)
gnome-desktop	Package containing code shared among gnome-panel, gnome-session, nautilus, etc
gnome-doc-utils	Documentation utilities for GNOME
gnome-python2	The sources for the PyGNOME Python extension module
gnome-terminal	Terminal emulator for GNOME
google-gadgets	Google Gadgets for Linux
gutenprint	Printer Drivers Package.
hplip	HP Linux Imaging and Printing Project
hsqldb	Hsqldb Database Engine
ImageMagick	An X application for displaying and manipulating images
imsettings	Delivery framework for general Input Method configuration
ipmitool	Utility for IPMI control
ipv6calc	IPv6 address format change and calculation utility
isomd5sum	Utilities for working with md5sum implanted in ISO images
jack-audio-connection-kit	The Jack Audio Connection Kit
jakarta-commons-codec	Implementations of common encoders and decoders
jakarta-commons-net	Internet protocol suite Java library
java-1.6.0-openjdk	OpenJDK Runtime Environment
javacc	A parser/scanner generator for java
k3b	CD/DVD burning application for KDE
kdeadmin	K Desktop Environment - Administrative tools
kdebase-runtime	K Desktop Environment - Runtime
kdebase-workspace	K Desktop Environment - Workspace
kdebindings	KDE bindings to non-C++ languages
kdegames	K Desktop Environment 4 - Games
kdegames3	K Desktop Environment 3 - Games not ported to KDE 4
kdegraphics	K Desktop Environment - Graphics Applications
kdelibs	K Desktop Environment 4 - Libraries
kdelibs3	K Desktop Environment 3 - Libraries
kdemultimedia	K Desktop Environment - Multimedia applications
kdenetwork	K Desktop Environment - Network Applications
kdepim	PIM (Personal Information Manager) applications
kdepimlibs	K Desktop Environment 4 - PIM Libraries
kdesdk	The KDE Software Development Kit (SDK)
kdeutils	K Desktop Environment - Utilities
kdewebdev	Web development applications
libdiscid	A Library for creating MusicBrainz DiscIDs
libfprint	Tool kit for fingerprint scanner
libgnomeui	GNOME base GUI library
libical	Reference implementation of the iCalendar data type and serialization format
liboil	Library of Optimized Inner Loops, CPU optimized functions
libwvstreams	WvStreams is a network programming library written in C++
libxslt	Library providing the Gnome XSLT engine
mc	User-friendly text console file manager and visual shell
mhash	Thread-safe hash algorithms library
mx	A collection of Python software tools
mx4j	Open source implementation of JMX Java API
netbeans-platform8	NetBeans Platform 8
ntfsprogs	NTFS filesystem libraries and utilities
objectweb-asm	A code manipulation tool to implement adaptable systems
opal	Open Phone Abstraction Library
openhpi	Hardware Platform Interface library and tools
pakchois	A wrapper library for PKCS#11
perl-Crypt-DES	Perl DES encryption module
perl-libwww-perl	A Perl interface to the World-Wide Web
perl-Net-SSLeay	Perl extension for using OpenSSL
perl-Tk	Perl Graphical User Interface ToolKit
php	PHP scripting language for creating dynamic web sites
php-pear	PHP Extension and Application Repository framework
ptlib	Portable Tools Library
PyQt4	Python bindings for Qt4
Pyrex	A compiler/language for writing Python extension modules
python-docs	Documentation for the Python programming language.
python-reportlab	Python PDF generation library
python-setuptools	Easily build and distribute Python packages
python-virtinst	Python modules and utilities for installing virtual machines
PyXML	XML libraries for python
qca-ossl	OpenSSL plugin for the Qt Cryptographic Architecture v2
qca2	Qt Cryptographic Architecture
qt	Qt toolkit
qt3	The shared library for the Qt 3 GUI toolkit
quagga	Routing daemon
redland	RDF Application Framework
ricci	Remote Cluster and Storage Management System
ruby	An interpreter of object-oriented scripting language
sane-backends	Scanner access software
scribus	DeskTop Publishing application written in Qt
setroubleshoot	Helps troubleshoot SELinux problems
stardict	A powerful dictionary platform written in GTK+2
system-config-bind	BIND DNS Configuration Tool
system-config-httpd	Apache configuration tool
system-config-kickstart	A graphical interface for making kickstart files
systemtap	Instrumentation System
texlive	Binaries for the TeX formatting system
tokyocabinet	A modern implementation of a DBM
torque	Tera-scale Open-source Resource and QUEue manager
unixODBC	A complete ODBC driver manager for Linux
uuid	Universally Unique Identifier library
xsane	X Window System front-end for the SANE scanner interface
yum-utils	Utilities based around the yum package manager

Legacy and low-priority

Package	Description	Notes
dump	Programs for backing up and restoring ext2/ext3 filesystems
xen	Xen is a virtual machine monitor
gnupg	A GNU utility for secure communication and data storage
beecrypt	An open source cryptography library
cyrus-imapd	A high-performance mail server with IMAP, POP3, NNTP and SIEVE support
uw-imap	UW Server daemons for IMAP and POP network mail protocols
inn	The InterNetNews system, an Usenet news server
nss_compat_ossl	Source-level compatibility library for OpenSSL to NSS porting
syslinux	Simple kernel loader which boots from a FAT filesystem
fetchmail	A remote mail retrieval and forwarding utility
w3m	A pager with Web browsing abilities
gnome-vfs2	The GNOME virtual file-system libraries
gthumb	Image viewer, editor, organizer
slrn	A threaded Internet news reader
compat-gcc-34	Compatibility GNU Compiler Collection
compat-db	The Berkeley DB database compatibility library
xdelta	A binary file delta generator and an RCS replacement library.
isdn4k-utils	Utilities for configuring an ISDN subsystem.
sharutils	The GNU shar utilities for packaging and unpackaging shell archives
busybox	Statically linked binary providing simplified versions of system commands

Configuration

Various packages support SHA-256, but their default configuration does not use it. Note that configuring the packages to use SHA-256 may prevent interoperability with systems that do not use SHA-256.

aide

Add the sha256 or sha512 group to your aide.conf.

krb5

On the KDC, add

master_key_type = aes256-cts
supported_enctypes = aes256-cts:normal

to your realm configuration in kdc.conf.

On all machines add the following to the [libedefaults] section of krb5.conf:

default_tgs_enctypes = aes256-cts-hmac-sha1-96
default_tkt_enctypes = aes256-cts-hmac-sha1-96
permitted_enctypes = aes256-cts-hmac-sha1-96
kdc_req_checksum_type = 12
ap_req_checksum_type = 12
safe_checksum_type = 12

nss_ldap

(After #487173 is applied, add information about pam_password and *rounds* here.)

pam

pam_unix uses DES to encrypt passwords by default. Add the sha256 or the sha512 option to use SHA-2. (This already the default in Fedora.)

rpm

To use SHA-256 in file digests, define the following RPM macros:

_source_filedigest_algorithm 8
_binary_filedigest_algorithm 8

(or just install redhat-rpm-config)

To use SHA-256 in PGP signatures, use an RSA key (at least 2048 bits recommended, otherwise the signature would be significantly weaker than the hash), and define the following RPM macro when signing the packages:

__gpg_sign_cmd %{__gpg} gpg --force-v3-sigs --digest-algo sha256 --batch --no-verbose --no-armor --passphrase-fd 3 --no-secmem-warning -u "%{_gpg_name}" -sbo %{__signature_filename} %{__plaintext_filename}

Done

These packages were already migrated, or the features that need migrating are not essential. The "Notes" column should contain enough information to migrate from SHA-256 to a stronger hash in the future.

Package	Description	Notes
amanda	A network-capable tape backup solution	Only uses HMAC-SHA-1 to authenticate to Amazon S3
aide	Intrusion detection environment	See #aide for configuration. Already supports SHA-256 and SHA-512 in the "file" backend, but not the SQL backend (#485250).
coreutils	A set of basic GNU tools commonly used in shell scripts	sha256sum et al are provided. sort -R uses MD-5 to generate random (but repeatable) comparison results.
dbus	D-BUS message bus	Only uses SHA-1 for DBUS_COOKIE_SHA1 authentication, which is not used in Fedora (#485277).
glibc	The GNU libc libraries	crypt() already supports SHA-256 and SHA-512. localedef uses MD5 to detect duplicate items when creating locale.archive without any collision handling (#485453).
nss_db	An NSS library for the Berkeley DB	The integrated db4: Uses SHA-1 to derive encryption and MAC keys from passwords. Uses HMAC-SHA1 to verify integrity of encrypted pages.
nss_ldap	NSS library and PAM module for LDAP	Uses MD5 only to generate password salts. Depending on pam_password, may use DES or MD5 crypt() for modified userPassword (verification is done on server, and OpenLDAP appears to support SHA-2); patch for adding support for SHA-2 to pam_ldap is in #487173.
pam_pkcs11	PKCS #11/NSS PAM login module	Signs a SHA-1 hash of a random value to verify user's control of a token, SHA-1 used only as a transformation of the random data (the token signs the hash, not the data). digest_mapper indexes certificates using a digest, using any algorithm supported by the crypto library.
pam_smb	A Pluggable Authentication Module (PAM) for use with SMB servers.	Uses MD4 and DES as part of SMB authentication.
rpm	The RPM package management system	Already supports SHA-256 for RPMTAG_FILEDIGESTS. Already supports SHA-256 in public key signatures (RSA v3 signatures only). User interface for file digests often says "md5" (#487597). Some tags hard-code hash types: RPMSIGTAG_MD5, RPMSIGTAG_SHA1, RPMSIGTAG_DSA (hard-coded SHA-1). Public key fingerprint computation uses SHA-1.
yum	RPM installer/updater	Computes MD5, SHA-1 and SHA-256 hashes of repomd.xml to be verified against metalink data. Verifies hashes of repodata files, and of downloaded packages, using hashes specified in the repodata. Uses MD5 and SHA-1 to compute PGP key fingerprints. Verifies installed files using the hash specified in FILEDIGESTALGO.
udev	A userspace implementation of devfs	MD5 is used for generation of UUID of the macitosh file system HFS. USE_MAKEDEV_CACHE uses MD5 of a makedev.d file to generate a processed version, without any collision checking; could be exploited only by system administrator.