User:Jlaska/autoqa package dependencies

This page outlines the effort involved to package autoqa, and it's dependencies, for Fedora.

Key

The following table details the different icons and states used through this page.

Unknown unknown Unknown	Unknown status, needs investigation
inprogress Inprogress	Currently assigned and inprogress, see Notes for details
pass Complete	This means it is packaged for Fedora or is considered not an issue, see Notes for details
warn Warning	Needs further review, see Notes for details
fail Failure	Not packaged for Fedora, or unable to package for Fedora, see Notes for details.

Bundled JAR files

The gwt package has many runtime and build requirements. As currently distributed, the requirements are bundled with the source code. This practice if forbidden according to the Fedora Java packaging guidelines (see Packaging:Java#Pre-built_JAR_files_.2F_Other_bundled_software). To address this issue, the gwt.spec should be updated as follows:

1. Add package relationship dependencies (%Requires for run-time or %Buildrequires for build-time)
2. In the %build phase, replace the bundled JAR file with a symlink to the system JAR file

For each of the JAR files listed below, the goal is to identify the Fedora package that provides the JAR file. Some steps to help locate the package.

1. Identify whether it is a build or run-time requirement for gwt
2. Determine whether the JAR file is provided by an existing package

   # Obtain a list of packages that contain a file matching the glob: *xerces*.jar
   $ repoquery -q -f "*xerces*jar"
   

3. If not available in Fedora, determine whether the JAR file is available in a JPackage rpm
4. If not available in JPackage, locate upstream and start packaging for Fedora

A build option is provided to assist with packaging gwt. To build gwt with all bundled JAR files, use rpmbuild option --with bundled_jars. To build gwt without the bundled JAR files (default), use rpmbuild option --without bundled_jars.

File	Required by	Status	Notes
tools/api-checker/reference/gwt-user-modified.jar	gwt	pass	I believe this is provided by gwt and acceptable
tools/api-checker/reference/gwt-dev-modified.jar	gwt	pass	I believe this is provided by gwt and acceptable
tools/lib/htmlunit/htmlunit-core-js-r5070.jar	gwt	inprogress	packaged for jpackage, see #RPM dependencies below for packaging status
tools/lib/htmlunit/htmlunit-core-js-2.5.jar	gwt	inprogress	packaged for jpackage, see #RPM dependencies below for packaging status
tools/lib/htmlunit/htmlunit-r5070.jar	gwt	inprogress	packaged for jpackage, see #RPM dependencies below for packaging status
tools/lib/htmlunit/htmlunit-core-js-r5070-sources.jar	gwt	pass	packaged for jpackage, see #RPM dependencies below for packaging status. However, not a true build requirement. Safe to ignore.
tools/lib/htmlunit/htmlunit-2.5.jar	gwt	inprogress	packaged for jpackage, see #RPM dependencies below for packaging status
tools/lib/htmlunit/htmlunit-2.5-sources.jar	gwt	pass	packaged for jpackage, see #RPM dependencies below for packaging status. However, not a true build requirement. Safe to ignore.
tools/lib/htmlunit/htmlunit-r5070-sources.jar	gwt	pass	packaged for jpackageA, see #RPM dependencies below for packaging status. However, not a true build requirement. Safe to ignore.
tools/lib/htmlunit/htmlunit-core-js-2.5-sources.jar	gwt	pass	packaged for jpackage, see #RPM dependencies below for packaging status. However, not a true build requirement. Safe to ignore.
tools/lib/jetty/jetty-6.1.11.jar	gwt	pass	jetty
tools/lib/nekohtml/nekohtml-1.9.12.jar	gwt	warn	Available as nekohtml-0.9.5-6.2 - may need a newer build. nekohtml-1.9.14-1 is being packaged for rawhide.
tools/lib/nekohtml/nekohtml-1.9.13.jar	gwt	warn	Available as nekohtml-0.9.5-6.2 - may need a newer build. nekohtml-1.9.14-1 is being packaged for rawhide.
tools/lib/selenium/selenium-java-client-driver-sources.jar	gwt	pass	Can't find this specific JAR file in selenium-java-client-driver. However, not a true build requirement. Safe to ignore.
tools/lib/selenium/1.0.1/selenium-java-client-driver-sources.jar	gwt	pass	Can't find this specific JAR file in selenium-java-client-driver. However, not a true build requirement. Safe to ignore.
tools/lib/selenium/1.0.1/selenium-java-client-driver.jar	gwt	pass	selenium-java-client-driver
tools/lib/selenium/1.0.1/selenium-server-sources.jar	gwt	pass	Can't find the sources.jar file anywhere. However, not a true build requirement. Safe to ignore.
tools/lib/selenium/1.0.1/selenium-server.jar	gwt	pass	selenium-server is probably what we want, although perl-Alien-SeleniumRC also provides this file.
tools/lib/selenium/selenium-java-client-driver.jar	gwt	pass	selenium-java-client-driver
tools/lib/selenium/selenium-server-sources.jar	gwt	pass	Can't find the sources.jar file anywhere. However, not a true build requirement. Safe to ignore.
tools/lib/selenium/selenium-server.jar	gwt	pass	selenium-server is probably what we want, although perl-Alien-SeleniumRC also provides this file.
tools/lib/protobuf/protobuf-2.2.0/protobuf-java-2.2.0.jar	gwt	pass	protobuf is available, but does not build the protobuf-java subpackage containing the .jar file. I have reached out to protobuf maintainers, and listed protobuf below in #RPM dependencies as packaging work will be required. protobuf-2.3.0-3.fc14 is now available.
tools/lib/protobuf/protobuf-2.2.0/protobuf-java-rebased-2.2.0.jar	gwt	pass	Not packaged, see project page, see #RPM dependencies below for packaging status. This should be covered by protobuf-2.3.0-3.fc14, which is now available.
tools/lib/eclipse/jdt-3.1.1.jar	gwt	pass	eclipse-jdt
tools/lib/eclipse/org.eclipse.swt.win32-win32-3.2.1.jar	gwt	pass	windows jar file not needed in fedora
tools/lib/eclipse/org.eclipse.swt.carbon-macosx-3.2.1.jar	gwt	pass	osx jar file not needed in fedora
tools/lib/eclipse/org.eclipse.swt.gtk-linux-3.2.1.jar	gwt	pass	eclipse-swt
tools/lib/eclipse/jdt-3.3.1.jar	gwt	pass	eclipse-jdt
tools/lib/eclipse/jdt-3.4.2.jar	gwt	pass	eclipse-jdt
tools/lib/cssparser/cssparser-0.9.5.jar	gwt	pass	cssparser is only available in rawhide at the moment. This is fine for now. Will handle rebasing older releases at a later time.
tools/lib/tomcat/commons-logging-1.0.jar	gwt	pass	ant-commons-logging or jakarta-commons-logging
tools/lib/tomcat/tomcat-util-5.1.jar	gwt	pass	tomcat5-server-lib
tools/lib/tomcat/jasper-compiler-1.0.jar	gwt	pass	tomcat5-jasper
tools/lib/tomcat/catalina-1.0.jar	gwt	pass	tomcat5-server-lib or tomcat6-lib
tools/lib/tomcat/ant-launcher-1.6.5.jar	gwt	pass	ant
tools/lib/tomcat/naming-resources-1.0.jar	gwt	pass	tomcat5-common-lib or directory-naming
tools/lib/tomcat/tomcat-jk2-2.1.jar	gwt	fail	Cannot find tomcat-jk2 in any Fedora packages. This may not be a problem since mod_jk2 has been deprecated upstream (according to tomcat5 %changelog).
tools/lib/tomcat/tomcat-coyote-1.0.jar	gwt	pass	tomcat5-server-lib or tomcat6-lib
tools/lib/tomcat/naming-java-1.0.jar	gwt	pass	directory-naming
tools/lib/tomcat/servlet-api-2.4.jar	gwt	pass	tomcat5-servlet-2.4-api
tools/lib/tomcat/mx4j-jmx-1.1.jar	gwt	pass	mx4j
tools/lib/tomcat/commons-el-1.0.jar	gwt	pass	jakarta-commons-el
tools/lib/tomcat/tomcat-http11-1.0.jar	gwt	pass	Can't find this packaged, but inspecting the JAR file, I believe this is provided by tomcat5-server-lib or tomcat6-lib
tools/lib/tomcat/servlets-common-1.0.jar	gwt	pass	tomcat5-server-lib
tools/lib/tomcat/jsp-api-2.0.jar	gwt	pass	tomcat5-jsp-2.0-api
tools/lib/tomcat/commons-modeler-1.1.jar	gwt	pass	jakarta-commons-modeler
tools/lib/tomcat/commons-beanutils-1.6.jar	gwt	pass	jakarta-commons-beanutils
tools/lib/tomcat/jsp-api-2.1.jar	gwt	pass	tomcat6-jsp-2.1-api
tools/lib/tomcat/commons-collections-3.1.jar	gwt	pass	jakarta-commons-collections
tools/lib/tomcat/servlets-invoker-1.0.jar	gwt	pass	tomcat5-server-lib
tools/lib/tomcat/servlets-default-1.0.jar	gwt	pass	tomcat5-server-lib
tools/lib/tomcat/catalina-optional-1.0.jar	gwt	pass	tomcat5-server-lib
tools/lib/tomcat/jakarta-regexp-1.3.jar	gwt	pass	eclipse-quickrex or ant-apache-regexp
tools/lib/tomcat/servlet-api-2.5.jar	gwt	pass	tomcat6-servlet-2.5-api
tools/lib/tomcat/naming-common-1.0.jar	gwt	pass	I think this is provided by tomcat5-common-lib
tools/lib/tomcat/jasper-runtime-1.0.jar	gwt	pass	tomcat5-jasper
tools/lib/tomcat/commons-digester-1.5.jar	gwt	pass	jakarta-commons-digester
tools/lib/tomcat/ant-launcher-1.7.1.jar	gwt	pass	ant
tools/lib/tomcat/naming-factory-1.0.jar	gwt	pass	tomcat5-common-lib or directory-naming
tools/lib/junit/junit-3.8.1.jar	gwt	pass	junit
tools/lib/jfreechart/jcommon-1.0.6.jar	gwt	pass	jcommon
tools/lib/jfreechart/jfreechart-1.0.3.jar	gwt	pass	jfreechart
tools/lib/jfreechart/itext-1.4.6.jar	gwt	pass	itext
tools/lib/sun/swingworker/swing-worker-1.1.jar	gwt	pass	netbeans-java
tools/lib/javaswf/javaswf-20050404.jar	gwt	fail	Not packaged anywhere and I question whether this is needed. There has been no activity on this project since 2003. See project page.
tools/lib/cglib/cglib-2.2.jar	gwt	pass	cglib
tools/lib/cglib/cglib-src-2.2.jar	gwt	pass	not provided by cglib. However, not a true build requirement. Safe to ignore.
tools/lib/xerces/xerces-2_9_1/xml-apis.jar	gwt	warn	can't find this, perhaps xml-commons-apis?
tools/lib/xerces/xerces-2_9_1/xercesimpl-nometainf.jar	gwt	warn	can't find this in fedora package
tools/lib/xerces/xerces-2_9_1/serializer.jar	gwt	warn	can't find this in fedora package
tools/lib/xerces/xerces-2_9_1/xercesimpl.jar	gwt	warn	can't find this in fedora package
tools/lib/xerces/xerces-2.0.2.jar	gwt	pass	xerces-j2
tools/lib/xerces/xml-apis-2.0.2.jar	gwt	warn	is this the same as xml-commons-apis?
tools/lib/xalan/xalan-2.7.1.jar	gwt	pass	xalan-x2
tools/lib/apache/tapestry-util-text-4.0.2.jar	gwt	fail	Packaged for jpackage, see #RPM dependencies below for packaging status
tools/lib/apache/commons/commons-codec-1.3.jar	gwt	pass	jakarta-commons-codec
tools/lib/apache/commons/commons-logging-1.1.1.jar	gwt	pass	jakarta-commons-logging
tools/lib/apache/commons/commons-io-1.4.jar	gwt	pass	jakarta-commons-io
tools/lib/apache/commons/commons-httpclient-3.1.jar	gwt	pass	jakarta-commons-httpclient
tools/lib/apache/commons/commons-collections-3.2.1.jar	gwt	pass	jakarta-commons-collections
tools/lib/apache/commons/commons-lang-2.4.jar	gwt	pass	jakarta-commons-lang
tools/lib/apache/ant-1.6.5.jar	gwt	pass	ant
tools/lib/apache/ant-1.6.1.jar	gwt	pass	ant
tools/lib/apache/ant-1.7.1.jar	gwt	pass	ant
tools/lib/w3c/sac/sac-1.3.jar	gwt	pass	sac
tools/lib/w3c/sac/sac-1.3-src.jar	gwt	pass	not provided by sac, not a true build requirement. Safe to ignore.
tools/lib/w3c/flute/flute-1.3-gg1.jar	gwt	pass	Seems to be a hand-patched version of flute to add a new file (see commit log). Inspecting the flute.jar provided by flute shows it also contains the missing encoding.properties file
tools/lib/w3c/flute/flute-1.3.jar	gwt	pass	flute
tools/lib/w3c/flute/flute-1.3-gg1-src.jar	gwt	pass	Not provided in flute, not a true build requirement. Safe to ignore.
tools/lib/w3c/flute/flute-1.3-src.jar	gwt	pass	not provided in flute, not a true build requirement. Safe to ignore.
tools/lib/tonicsystems/jarjar-1.0rc8.jar	gwt	warn	jarjar-0.9-5 is available, but may require an update.
tools/lib/objectweb/asm-util-3.1.jar	gwt	pass	objectweb-asm
tools/lib/objectweb/asm-tree-3.1.jar	gwt	pass	objectweb-asm
tools/lib/objectweb/asm-commons-3.1.jar	gwt	pass	objectweb-asm
tools/lib/objectweb/asm-xml-3.1.jar	gwt	pass	objectweb-asm
tools/lib/objectweb/asm-analysis-3.1.jar	gwt	pass	objectweb-asm
tools/lib/objectweb/asm-3.1.jar	gwt	pass	objectweb-asm
tools/lib/easymock/easymock.jar	gwt	pass	easymock
tools/lib/easymock/easymockclassextension.jar	gwt	pass	easymock
dev/core/test/com/google/gwt/dev/resource/impl/testdata/cpe2.jar	gwt	pass	Thsi is built and provided by the gwt package itself. This is fine.
dev/core/test/com/google/gwt/dev/resource/impl/testdata/cpe1.jar	gwt	pass	This is built and provided by the gwt package itself. This is fine.
eclipse/settings/code-style/gwt-customchecks.jar	gwt	pass	According to the svn log, this provides a file used for gwt development within eclipse. Safe to ignore.

RPM dependencies

The following table lists the package dependencies required to build autoqa and their Fedora package review status. Unless otherwise stated, builds for these packages should be available in Fedora 14. At some point, building packages into Fedora 13, or EPEL5, may be desired, but starting with Fedora 14 is ideal.

Package	Required by	Status	Notes
autoqa-0.3.5-pre2.fc13	QA	Unknown unknown
autotest-0.12.0-1.fc13	autoqa	Unknown unknown
Django-1.0.4-1.fc13	autotest	Unknown unknown	A newer version of Django is available in Fedora, but Django-1.0.4-1 is needed. A contrib package will be required so that Django and contrib-Django-1.0.4 can coexist
gwt-2.0.3-0.1.fc13	autotest	Unknown unknown
htmlunit-2.7-1	gwt	inprogress jlaska	Preliminary dist-f14 package available at http://jlaska.fedorapeople.org/autoqa/rpms/htmlunit/. Next step ... Fedora package review.
maven-checkstyle-plugin	htmlunit	pass spike	maven-checkstyle-plugin-2.5-1.fc14 is now available in rawhide (see review request RHBZ #614836).
xalan-js	htmlunit	inprogress jlaska	xalan-j2-2.7.1-1.fc14 is available but missing the required .pom files. With heavy lifting from dbhole. Proposed xalan-j2 package updates are available at http://jlaska.fedorapeople.org/autoqa/rpms/xalan-j2/. I have contacted the xalan-j2 maintainer requesting a rebuild.
nekohtml-1.9.14	htmlunit	pass jlaska	nekohtml-1.9.14-2 is now available in rawhide.
htmlunit-core-js-2.7-1	htmlunit	inprogress jlaska	Preliminary dist-f14 package available at http://jlaska.fedorapeople.org/autoqa/rpms/htmlunit-core-js/. Next step ... Fedora package review.
tapestry-4.0.2-3.jpp5	gwt	Unknown unknown
protobuf-2.3.0	gwt	pass jlaska	protobuf-java is now available in rawhide (see protobuf)
ecj-3.4.2-7.el5	gwt	pass jlaska	ecj is available in rawhide (an el5).
cssparser	gwt	pass jlaska	cssparser is currently available in rawhide, but not in fc13 or el5. According to User:Akurtakov, rebuilding cssparser requires javacc-maven-plugin in Fedora 13, and building anything *maven* in F13 is broken+problematic.
sac-1.3-8	cssparser	pass jlaska	A newer version of sac is needed in Fedora 13. Requested CVS tagging to build into fc13. Currently, sac-1.3-8 is now available in fc14 and fc13.